sábado, 22 de junho de 2024

The joy of being animal

 

Jenny Marvin


Human exceptionalism is dead: 
for the sake of 
our own happiness and the planet 
we should embrace 
our true animal nature.



When I visited my grandmother at the undertakers, an hour or so before her funeral, I was struck by how different death is from sleep. A sleeping individual shimmers with fractional movements. The dead seem to rest in paused animation, so still they look smaller than in life. It’s almost impossible not to feel as if something very like the soul is no longer present. Yet my grandmother had also died with Alzheimer’s. Even in life, something of who she was had begun to abandon her. And I wondered, as her memories vanished, had she become a little less herself, a little less human?

These end-of-life stages prick our imaginations. They confront us with some unsettling ideas. We don’t like to face the possibility that irreversible biological processes in our bodies can snuff out the stunning light of our individual experience. We prefer to deny our bodies altogether, and push away the dark tendrils of a living world we fear. The trouble for us is that this story – that we aren’t really our bodies but some special, separate ‘thing’ – has made a muddle of reality. 

Problems flow from the notion that we’re split between a superior human half and the inferior, mortal body of an animal. In short, we’ve come to believe that our bodies and their feelings are a lesser kind of existence. 
But what if we’re wrong? 
What if all parts of us, including our minds, are deeply biological, and our physical experiences are far more meaningful and richer than we’ve been willing to accept?

As far as we know, early hunter-gatherer animist societies saw spirit everywhere. 
All life possessed a special, non-physical essence. 
In European classical thought, many also believed that every living thing had a soul. 
But souls were graded. Humans were thought to have a superior soul within a hierarchy. 
By the time of theologians such as the Italian Dominican friar and philosopher Thomas Aquinas, in the 13th century, this soulful view of life had retreated, leaving humans the only creature still in possession of an immortal one. 

As beings with a unique soul, we were more than mere animals. Our lives were set on a path to salvation. Life was now a great chain of being, with only the angels and God above us.

But, as the Middle Ages came to a close in the 16th century, a fresh, apparently rational form of exceptionalism began to spread. The origins for this shift lie in the thinking of René Descartes, who gave the world a new version of dualism. 
Descartes argued that thought is so different from the physical, machine-like substance of the body that we should see humans as having two parts: the thoughtful mind and the thoughtless, physical body. 
This was religion refocused through a rational lens. 
 
The division between humans and the rest of nature was no longer the soul – or, at least, not only the soul – but rather our intellectual capabilities: our reason, our moral sensibilities, our gifts for abstraction. He assumed, of course, that other animals don’t think.

Enlightenment figures such as John Locke and Immanuel Kant in the 17th and 18th centuries developed this further. According to them, it was the fruits of our intelligence that made us truly human. Through mental powers, humans live more meaningfully than other beings. In other words, we humans have a soulful mind. It was even suggested that we are our thoughts, and that these phantasmal mental aspects of humans are more important and even, daringly, separable from the impoverished biology that we share with other animals.

In many ways, Darwinism posed a threat to this intensifying vision of the human and our place in nature. Charles Darwin disrupted both the idea of a neat divide between humans and other forms of life, and also complicated the possibilities for mind-body dualism. If humans had evolved from earlier, ancestral primates, then our minds, too, must have emerged through ordinary, evolutionary processes with deep roots in nature. It’s easy to forget today just how shattering Darwinism was for a whole generation. Darwin himself wrote to his friend, the American botanist Asa Gray, to express his acute fear of seeing humans as a fully integrated part of a seemingly amoral natural world, where there’s ‘too much misery’. Perhaps we shouldn’t be surprised, then, to find the redoubling of efforts to assert new forms of human redemption in the years after publication of On the Origin of Species (1859).

One such effort came in the form of the ‘human revolution’ – the idea that some kind of cognitive leap took place in the recent evolution of Homo sapiens that forever split us from other species. Another was in the 20th-century reworking of Enlightenment humanism that sought to find scientific proofs of human exception, and to argue that only these ultimately matter. Modern humanism promised to be about the ‘complete realisation of human personality’ in an onward march ‘to move farther into space and perhaps inhabit other planets’. The history of global philosophy on humans and other animals might be mischievously summarised as a long study in mental bias.

Today, our thinking has shifted along with scientific evidence, incorporating the genetic insights of the past century. 
We now know we’re animals, related to all other life on our planet. 
We’ve also learned much about cognition, including the uneasy separation between instinct and intention, and the investment of the whole body in thought and action. 
As such, we might expect attitudes to have changed. But that isn’t the case. 
  1. We still live with the belief that humans, in some essential way, aren’t really animals. 
  2. We still cling to the possibility that there’s something extrabiological that delivers us from the troubling state of being an organism trapped by flesh and death. 

In the words of the philosopher Derek Parfit, 
‘the body below the neck is not an essential part of us.’ 

Many of us still deny that human actions are the result of our animal being, instead maintaining that they’re the manifestation of reason. We think our world into being. And that’s sometimes true. 
The trouble comes when we think our thoughts are our being.

There are real-world consequences to these ideas. 
Having a humanlike mind has become a moral dividing line. 

In our courts, we determine what we can and can’t do to other sentient beings on the basis of the absence of a mind with features like ours. 
Those things that look too disturbingly body-centred, like impulse or agency, regardless of their outcomes or role in flourishing, are viewed as lower down on the moral scale. 
Meanwhile, the view that physical, animal properties (many of which we share with other species) have little significance has left us with the absurd idea that we can live without our bodies. 

So it is that we pursue biological enhancement in search of the true essence of our humanity. 
Some of the world’s largest biotech companies are developing not only artificial forms of intelligence but brain-machine interfaces in the hope that we might one day achieve superintelligence or even mental immortality by downloading our minds into a synthetic form. 
It follows that our bodies, our flesh and our feelings – from laughing with our friends to listening to music to cuddling our children – can be seen as a threat to this paradigm.


Why is this animal-denialism so entrenched in the human psyche, across cultures and millennia of time? 
The orthodox (if, still, speculative) story from evolutionary biology, as suggested by figures such as the American zoologist Richard Alexander in the 1970s, is that our subjective, imaginative mind has its origins in a bundle of adaptations for social cognition. As primates who lived in groups, our ancestors needed one another to survive; yet their social environment was also competitive, making the need patchy enough to empower the kind of cognition that gives us our sense of ‘me’. 
Add to that the need to gather insight into our own motivations and those of others, and to incorporate a rich, layered memory of experience, and we’re left with a staggering attention to internal states and external stimuli – the exact flavour of which consciousness researchers endlessly battle about. 
These many biological routes to attention gift us our selfhood.

Unfortunately for us, this self-salience has left us with the bizarre sensation that who we really are is some kind of floating mind, our identity a kind of thinking, or rather, a thinking about thinking, rather than the whole feeling, sensing, sometimes instinctual colony of cells that makes up the entire unit of our animal being. 

Our selfhood gives rise to the sensation that we’re a thing trapped inside a body. 
And we can speculate that several things flow from this. 
We have a heightened awareness of the threats we face as animals – not least an awareness that we’ll die one day. 

As W B Yeats put it in his poem ‘Sailing to Byzantium’ (1928), 
we are ‘fastened to a dying animal’. 
And, because we feel as if we’re somehow more than our bodies, we’re reassured that we can escape the frightening limits of our flesh. 

In other words, 
our sensation of mental distinctiveness becomes our hope for salvation.

But humans don’t only have selfhood – we also have insight into other selves. 
By making sound judgments about the internal states of others and communicating as we do, we have an extraordinary network of exchanges available to us. 
When the pathogen SARS-CoV-2 hit our societies causing havoc and heartbreak, we nonetheless had systems of communication, healthcare infrastructure, and methods for understanding the virus that would be impossible without the biological mechanisms that encourage us to work together for shared benefit. 

One of the glues of our cooperation is our ability to think into and make judgments about each other’s minds, experiences and intentions.


There’s still more evidence for the adaptive nature of cooperation in something we’ve come to call ‘social buffering’. 
This is the way that measurable stress can be reduced by proximity to a member of our community. Closeness and good relationships affect our wellbeing, modulating the release of stress hormones such as cortisol that can suppress our immune systems. 

A hug, the holding of a partner’s hands during a tough situation, access to our group in times of stress – all these create measurable effects on our health, and improve our ability to cope with the knocks of life. These benefits accumulate across a lifetime and have been found elsewhere among group-living animals, especially mammals.

But it’s a little more complicated for an animal like us. 
We use ideas to bring about the kinds of buffering responses created by our relationships. 
Where other social animals gain support by physical proximity to a relative or group-member, humans gain this through psychological proximity as well. 

In other words, the ideas that bring us together have physical consequences. This buffering is active for any worldview or ideology that facilitates group-belonging – and that might be something as innocuous as a local football team.

But there’s a little twist in this tale.

Evidence shows that social buffering often involves ranking the minds and skills of our own group (including the largest set, the Homo sapiens) as higher than those of others. 

Research by the Dutch psychologist Carsten De Dreu has revealed how some of the beliefs about the superior mental content of our own groups affect oxytocin, reinforcing our bonds with each other and increasing our commitment to the thoughts and feelings of our compatriots. 

Elsewhere, the work of the Italian psychologist Jeroen Vaes has demonstrated how fears and dangers prompt people to renew their group bonds, and this includes seeing group members as more human than those outside the group (with ‘more human’ measured as individuals with higher intelligence and greater signals of secondary emotions such as empathy or pride). 

In other words, we see the minds of our own group as superior to the minds of those on the outside, and when we want to reinforce that – especially, if we feel under threat – we increase our beliefs in the superior judgment of our own centre of belonging, and can denigrate anyone or anything that contradicts this. While that ‘group’ is often the culture or ideology with which we identify, for humans that group can also simply be us.

Intriguingly, recent studies have shown that the idea that we’re not really animals – and especially the idea that humans are hierarchically superior forms of life – is one of those profoundly reassuring ideas that we favour. 

Nour Kteily, a researcher at Northwestern University in Illinois, studies the ways that groups of people interact. He has developed the ‘ascent of man measure’, which exploits the progressive idea of humans rising to the top of a biological hierarchy. What he found is that stress or the presence of threats can prime us to favour human uniqueness. 
This generates a curious paradox, of course, if we view being animal as a threat in and of itself.

So why does this matter now? 
Nobody is denying that humans are exceptional. 
The concept of human uniqueness is only a problem when we deny the beauty and necessity both of our animal lives and the lives of other animals. 

No matter whether our origin stories tell us we’re possessors of spiritual properties or our courts tell us we’re ‘persons’ with dignity, we privilege the transcendent over the physical. The root word for ‘exception’ is the Latin excipere, which means ‘to take out’. 
 
We have always longed to be saved, to be ‘taken out’ from what we dislike or fear of our animal condition. But the pursuit of escape becomes more serious once we have powerful technologies to engineer and exploit biology.

These days, there is substantial investment in different technical routes to escape the limits or dangers of being animal, whether through DNA repair or stem-cell treatments or the transfer of more and more of ourselves to synthetic or machine forms. 
Google, Amazon and Elon Musk’s Neuralink are just three of the major corporations working in some of these areas. 
These are all part of a general trend to control and technologise more and more of our animal life. 
But, in seeking ways to enhance ourselves, people rarely acknowledge what we’d be leaving behind. 

As we start to use these new powers, it’s imperative that we dwell on what we stand to lose. 
The point here is not to argue that we ought to act as animals but rather that we are animals, and that a huge amount of the quality of our experience lies in a fully embodied animal life.

Some of the most important stages of life happen in the womb and in the early bonds with our carers in the weeks and months after birth. And the quality of those bonds and the wellbeing of our mothers can have lasting effects on us and the people we come to be. 

As the Israeli psychologist Ruth Feldman has written: 
‘Later attachments … repurpose the basic machinery established by the mother-offspring bond during early “sensitive periods”.’ 

These crucial years in human development involve crosstalk between hormones, environment and touch that influence how the baby’s neural networks are organised. 
The central nervous system, the resilience to stress, all bear the marks of the early, deeply embodied years of our lives. 
When a parent and child embrace, the effects are staggering, regulating body temperature, heart rate and respiration. 

People in a temporary alliance, whether queer or straight, old or young, conservative or liberal, synch in ways that are measurable, from hormonal shifts to oscillations of the gamma and alpha rhythms of our brains, and these nourishing alliances reservice those first intimate, mammalian bonds.

Far from being solely the product of our brains and self-direction, then, humans are intimately affected by their whole physical being and its environment. 
Some devastating evidence for this comes from the children of Romania’s orphanages, who were abandoned with little physical or sensory affection by the cruelties and excesses of the country’s leader Nicolae Ceaușescu’s regime. This neglect left them with lifelong struggles, extending to language delays and visual-spatial disruption. 

These are painful reminders that our ability to flourish and express ourselves is profoundly influenced by the way our bodies are treated and valued in the earliest stages of our lifecycle.

And that should matter to those who seek ways to define what’s important about human life. 
There’s the exciting possibility to some in the research and business community that we might soon exploit new biotechnologies such as the CRISPR gene and genome-editing tool, or have access to a kind of embryo ‘agriculture’ through frontier reproductive tools such as in-vitro gametogenesis (a technology that enables the switch from something like a skin cell into a stem cell), and thereby select the most disease-resistant or intelligence-scored embryos as our children. 

It’s of note, however, that the pursuit of this would disrupt and industrialise human life from its inception. In other words, we wouldn’t make our babies through sex, and nurturing might be done by engineering rather than by love and touch.

In less dramatic disruptions, we’re increasingly turning over our lives to our smartphones, with little attention paid to how our whole bodies influence who we become and how we thrive. 

The fact that children learn better through physical movement and gesture, including language acquisition, is ignored by those who want to operationalise teaching online. The research community is troublingly divided on how time online affects our mental and physical wellbeing. Studies from equally reputable sources announce that social media doesn’t affect mental health at the same time as another provides convincing evidence that it does. 
But a little common sense is useful here. 

What we can say for sure is that time online crowds out time spent in physical contact with others and in contact with the physical world. Only a belief that our animal lives are somehow less important than our mental lives can allow us to minimise what that reduction of our physical experience might mean.

And this is to say nothing of what our denigration of being animal means for the other animals. 
We have spent thousands of years arguing that we’re the moral overlords of our world. 
That’s looking harder to justify now that we’re the agents of extinction and pollution. 
For centuries, we have tamped down these contradictions. 
But it’s no longer possible to ignore the long shadow we cast. 
Mammal sizes have been shrinking on our watch, and are now the smallest they’ve been since dinosaurs roamed the Earth. Our planet’s biomass of mammals now breaks down into a mere 4 per cent wild species, around 30 per cent humans, and the rest are animals we produce for food.

Of course, as we explore our animal being, we’re confronted by the inconvenient possibility that these animals that are disappearing have worlds of experience that ought to press on our moral circuitry far harder than we’ve allowed up to now. 
Life on Earth is full of diverse forms of intelligence and purpose. 
We’re only at the beginning of scientific discoveries about the way memory and intentions grip animal bodies from tip to claw. Eventually, we’re going to have to reckon with the true complexity of the other lives that surround us. 
The more we learn about other animals, the more we recognise other experiences that ought to matter if, by this logic, our own do.

It might well be in the rallying of our own bodily resources that our greatest opportunities lie. 
When we reconsider all that we gain by being animals, we’re confronted by some powerful resources for positive change. 

Just think of the gobsmacking beauty of bonding. 
If you have a dog beside you as you read this, bend down, look into her eyes, and stroke her. Via the hypothalamus inside your body, oxytocin will get to work, and dopamine – organic chemicals implicated in animal bonding – and, before you know it, you’ll be feeling good, even in the dark times of a pandemic. And, as it happens, so will your dog, who will experience a similar physical response to the bond between you both. Oxytocin is produced in the hypothalamus of all mammals. 

In other words, our bodies might well be our best and most effective tool in the effort to strike a new balance between humans and the rest of the living world. 

If we can tip ourselves more into a bonding frame of mind, we might find it easier to recognise the beauty and intelligence that we’re hellbent on destroying. 
By accepting that we’re animals too, we create the opportunity to think about how we might play to the strengths of our evolutionary legacies in ways that we all stand to gain from. 
If we can build a better relationship with our own reality and, indeed, a better relationship with other animals, we’ll be on the road to recovery.


Melanie Challenger




segunda-feira, 17 de junho de 2024

The ship of Theseus








The ship of Theseus, 
also known as Theseus’ paradox, 
is a thought experiment that 
raises the question of 
whether an object that has had 
all of its components replaced 
remains fundamentally the same object.



Theseus’ ship was a useful thought puzzle to illustrate the seemingly unsolvable paradox of who we are. Who are we in the face of our growth and evolving identity?

The paradox asks whether a ship - the ship of Theseus - that had been restored by replacing every single wooden part remained the same ship.

Everything in the 3D world changes, transforms, and renews. 
The world as we see it today is totally different from the world that existed 10, 100, or 1000 years ago. Nature continuously blossoms and dies. 
Yet, there is a matrix of continuity.

Consider having two photos side by side of the same person, one picture shows the person in old age and the other picture shows the person in their youth. 
How is the person in the two pictures the same, and how are they different?

The body continually regenerates cells, and science tells us that after seven years, the entire body no longer has any of its original cells. Therefore, the human body, just like the Ship of Theseus, has come to be different to its original form, because the old parts have been replaced with new ones to create an entirely new object.

The cells in our body die too, to get replaced by new ones. There’s very little of us (just some brain and muscle cells) that is the same as 10 or 20 years ago.

  • Coming back to the Theseus paradox - if almost all the cells in our body are different from when we were born, can we say we are a different person? 
  • Is the ship of Theseus the same ship, after having replaced every single part?

Are You Still You?
The Ship of Theseus paradox may seem like an abstract thought experiment at first, but it holds significant implications for our understanding of personal identity and the nature of change over time. As we go through life, we all experience physical, emotional, mental, and spiritual changes that can alter our sense of self. 
How do we know that we are the same person we were five years ago?

Physically, our bodies are constantly changing. 
Our cells (with the exception of some brain cells and your eye lens) are constantly dying and being replaced, and we may undergo significant changes in appearance over time. For example, we may gain or lose weight, develop wrinkles or gray hair, or undergo surgeries that alter our physical form. 

Emotionally and mentally, we may also undergo significant changes over time. 
Our experiences and relationships shape our personalities and perspectives, and we may develop new beliefs or values that fundamentally alter who we are. 

Spiritually, we may also experience shifts in our beliefs or sense of purpose over time. We may undergo spiritual awakenings or crises that fundamentally alter our understanding of ourselves and the world around us. 

The paradox asks whether we are still the same person after these changes, or if we have become someone new.
How much of our identity is tied to our physical body, our memories and experiences, and our beliefs and values?

In a sense, we are all like the ship of Theseus. 
Constantly undergoing change and evolution, and our sense of self is not fixed or static. Instead, we are in a perpetual state of becoming, adapting to new experiences and challenges. Our physical bodies and personalities do not define us; rather, it is our deeper sense of self and purpose. By embracing this fluidity and recognizing the potential for growth and transformation, we can cultivate a deeper sense of self-awareness and acceptance, enabling us to navigate life’s changes with greater ease and resilience.



According to Aristotle, the ship of Theseus is the ‘same’ ship, because the formal cause, or design, does not change, even though the matter used to construct it may vary with time.

This suggests that it’s the design, or the DNA that defines our identity; to preserve this initial design, this DNA, there is continuous change and adaptation.

While our identity is in a continuous evolution, change, and renegotiation, there is an underlying direction that our ship sails toward.

While in the ocean of life, we may drift and adapt, we must always remember where our ship is heading. Why was it initially built for, what was its purpose?

And if we get stuck in a sandbar, that’s perhaps because there are parts of us that need more expression. Exploring the different facets of our identity and bringing forward both our inner twins doesn’t make us inauthentic or contradictory. It's a natural part of the journey called life.


In Greek mythology, Theseus, mythical king and founder of the city Athens, rescued the children of Athens from King Minos after slaying the minotaur and then escaped onto a ship going to Delos. Each year, the Athenians would commemorate this by taking the ship on a pilgrimage to Delos to honour Apollo. A question was raised by ancient philosophers: After several hundreds of years of maintenance, if each individual piece of the Ship of Theseus was replaced, one after the other, was it still the same ship?

In contemporary philosophy, this thought experiment has applications to the philosophical study of identity over time, and has inspired a variety of proposed solutions and concepts in contemporary philosophy of mind concerned with the persistence of personal identity.

The account of the problem has been preserved by Plutarch in his Life of Theseus:

The ship wherein Theseus and the youth of Athens returned from Crete had thirty oars, and was preserved by the Athenians down even to the time of Demetrius Phalereus, for they took away the old planks as they decayed, putting in new and stronger timber in their places, insomuch that this ship became a standing example among the philosophers, for the logical question of things that grow; one side holding that the ship remained the same, and the other contending that it was not the same.

— Plutarch, Life of Theseus 23.1

Over a millennium later, the philosopher Thomas Hobbes extended the thought experiment by supposing that a ship custodian gathered up all of the decayed parts of the ship as they were disposed of and replaced by the Athenians, and used those decaying planks to build a second ship. Hobbes posed the question of which of the two resulting ships, the custodian's or the Athenians', was the same ship as the "original" ship.

For if that Ship of Theseus (concerning the Difference whereof, made by continual reparation, in taking out the old Planks, and putting in new, the sophisters of Athens were wont to dispute) were, after all the Planks were changed, the same Numerical Ship it was at the beginning; and if some Man had kept the Old Planks as they were taken out, and by putting them afterward together in the same order, had again made a Ship of them, this, without doubt, had also been the same Numerical Ship with that which was at the beginnings and so there would have been two Ships Numerically the same, which is absurd... But we must consider by what name anything is called when we inquire concerning the Identity of it... so that a Ship, which signifies Matter so figured, will be the same, as long as the Matter remains the same; but if no part of the Matter is the same, then it is Numerically another Ship; and if part of the Matter remains, and part is changed, then the Ship will be partly the same, and partly not the same.

— Thomas Hobbes, "Of Identity and Difference"


Hobbes considers the two resulting ships as illustrating two definitions of "Identity" or sameness that are being compared to the original ship:

  1. the ship that maintains the same "Form" as the original, that which persists through complete replacement of material and;
  2. the ship made of the same "Matter", that which stops being 100 per cent the same ship when the first part is replaced.


According to other scientists, the thought puzzle arises because of extreme externalism: the assumption that what is true in our minds is true in the world. 
Noam Chomsky says that this is not an unassailable assumption, from the perspective of the natural sciences, because human intuition is often mistaken. Cognitive science would treat this thought puzzle as the subject of an investigation of the human mind. Studying this human confusion can reveal much about the brain's operation, but little about the nature of the human-independent external world.

Following on from this observation, a significant strand[who?] in cognitive science would consider the ship not as a thing, nor even a collection of objectively existing thing parts, but rather as an organisational structure that has perceptual continuity.

In Europe, several independent tales and stories feature knives that have had their blades and handles replaced several times but are still used and represent the same knife. 
  1. France has Jeannot's knife, 
  2. Spain uses Jeannot's knife as a proverb, though it is referred to simply as "the family knife",  
  3. Hungary has "Lajos Kossuth's pocket knife". 

Several variants or alternative statements of the underlying problem are known, including the grandfather's axe and Trigger's broom,where an old axe or broom has had both its head and its handle replaced, leaving no original components.

The Tin Woodman, a character in the fictional Land of Oz, was originally a man of flesh and blood, but all his body parts were replaced one by one by metal parts. nevertheless, he retains his identity.

The ancient Buddhist text Da zhidu lun contains a similar philosophical puzzle: a story of a traveller who encountered two demons in the night. As one demon ripped off all parts of the traveler's body one by one, the other demon replaced them with those of a corpse, and the traveller was confused about who he was.

The French critic and essayist Roland Barthes refers at least twice to a ship that is entirely rebuilt, in the preface to his Essais Critiques (1971) and later in his Roland Barthes par Roland Barthes (1975); in the latter, the persistence of the form of the ship is seen as a key structuralist principle. He calls this ship the Argo, on which Theseus was said to have sailed with Jason; he may have confused the Argo (referred to in passing in Plutarch's Theseus at 19.4) with the ship that sailed from Crete (Theseus, 23.1).

In Japan, the Ise Grand Shrine is rebuilt every twenty years with entirely "new wood". The continuity over the centuries is considered spiritual and comes from the source of the wood, which is harvested from an adjoining forest that is considered sacred.




Two-faced Janus, depicting old age and youth, 
by unknown Italian sculptor, late 18th century, via Hermitage Museum



  One of the more interesting challenges 
to the position that 
continuity of mental states 
characterizes a human being 
is the question of 
transitivity of identity. 



This discussion becomes far more interesting when we stop talking about ancient ships and start talking about human beings. 

  • Every person changes over time. 
  • We grow from infants to old people. 
  • What properties does a three-year-old have in common with their eighty-three-year-old self? 
  • These philosophical questions are called the problems of personal identity. 
  • What are the properties that make up a particular human being? 

We are not the same person we were several years ago. Nevertheless, we are still considered the same person.
  
Some thinkers push the notion that a person is essentially their body. 
We each have different bodies and can say that every person is identified with their body. By postulating that a human being is their body, we are subject to the same insoluble questions that we faced with the ship of Theseus and other physical objects. 

Our bodies are in constant flux. Old cells die and new cells are constantly being born. In fact, most of the cells in our body are replaced every seven years. 
This leads to hundreds of questions that philosophers have posed over the centuries. 
Why should a person stay in jail after seven years? After all, “he” did not perform the crime. It was someone else. Should a person own anything after seven years? The old person bought it. 
In what sense is a person the same after having a limb amputated? 

Science fiction writers are adept at discussing challenging questions like cloning, mind transfers, identical twins, conjoined twins, and other interesting topics related to the notion that a person is the same as their body. 
  1. When an ameba splits, which is the original and which is the daughter? 
  2. When your body loses cells it loses atoms. These atoms can go on to belong to others. Similarly, other peoples’ atoms can become part of your body. 
  3. What about death? We usually think in terms of the end of a person’s existence when they are dead even though the body is still there. Sometimes we use sentences like “She is buried there” as if “she” were still a person. And sometimes we use sentences like “His body is buried there” as if there is a difference between “him” and his body. 

In short, it is problematic to say that a human being is identified with their body.


Other thinkers favor the notion that a person is really their mental state or psyche. 
After all, human beings are not simply their bodies. 
A person is more than a physical object because there is thought. 
To such philosophers, a person is a continuous stream of consciousness—they are memories, intentions, thoughts, and desires. 

This leads us to ask other insoluble questions: 
  1. What if a person has amnesia? Are they the same person? 
  2. Doesn’t a person’s personality change over time? 
  3. Who is the real you: the one who is madly in love with someone or the one who is bored with the same person two months later? 

Literally hundreds of questions can be posed about change in a person’s thoughts, memories, and desires. 

Again, philosophers and science fiction writers have become quite adept at describing interesting scenarios that challenge our notion of a human being as a continuous stream of mental states. These scenarios are concerned with Alzheimer’s disease, amnesia, personality changes, split-brain experiments, multiple personality disorders, computers as minds, and so on. 

There are also many questions along the lines of the mind-body problem. 
How much is the mind—that characterizes a human being— independent of the brain, which is a part of the body?

One of the more interesting challenges to the position that continuity of mental states characterizes a human being is the question of transitivity of identity. 
My mental states are essentially the same as they were ten years ago. That means I am the same person I was ten years ago. Furthermore, ten years ago, my mental states were essentially the same as they were ten years earlier. Hence the person I was ten years ago is the same as the person I was twenty years ago. 

However, at present, I do not have similar mental states to those I had twenty years ago. So how can it be that I am the same person I was ten years ago, and that person is the same as I was twenty years ago, but I am not the same as I was twenty years ago?


Yet another option is that everyone has a unique soul that determines who they are. 
Avoiding the questions of the definition or existence of a soul, let us concentrate instead on how this answers our question of the essential nature of a human being. 
  1. Assuming the existence of a soul, what is the relationship between the soul and the body? 
  2. What is the relationship between a soul and a person’s actions, psyche, and personality? 
  3. If there is no connection, then in what sense is one soul different from another soul?
  4. How can you differentiate between souls—or identities, for that matter—if they have no influence over any part of you? What would the purpose of an identity be? 
  5. If, on the other hand, a connection exists, then does the identity change when the body, actions, psyche, or personality changes? 
  6. Is the soul in flux? 

If the identity does change, we are back to the same questions we had previously asked: 
  1. Who is the real you? 
  2. Are you the one with the soul prior to the change or are you the one with the changed soul?

Most people probably have an opinion 
representing some hybrid version 
of all three ideologies: 
a person is a composite of 
body, mind, and soul. 


Nevertheless, all schools of thought are somewhat problematic.
  



Zhao Chen


 

You’re going from point A to point B and then things fall apart catastrophically and you’re here. […] So you can think: Well, I’m who I was, that would be one kind of identity, I’m the person I thought I was. That blows apart. Then you’re in this terrible place and you think, oh, I’m the sort of person who’s in this terrible place. That’s another form of identify.

And then you can think: I’m not the old person or the person who was in the catastrophe, I’m the new person. But the problem is the new person can fall apart, too.

But then there’s a third way of thinking. This is a better way of thinking. I’m not this, or this, or this, I’m the process by which [the transformation] occurs. I know something, it’s not quite right. It collapses, it causes trouble (the collapse), but I regroup, I learn, I regenerate, I put myself back together and it happens again and it happens again. But each time it happens, maybe, you’re a little wiser, you’re a little more put together.

Jordan B. Peterson


Who are we in the face of our growth and evolving identity? 
Peterson conceptualises our identity as a story and suggests that we therefore shouldn’t look at ourselves as fixed states. Rather our identity is the driving force behind the transformation between the states — for the worse or for the better.

I can’t help but notice similarities to the Zen idea of the eternal now. It posits that the past and the future are mere illusions as there is only what happens in the never-ending moment. Paradoxically, this reduces our story to a single state. Reality is experienced only in the present. The past is in your mind only. The future is speculation.

Peterson’s thoughts are also a nod to personal agency and responsibility. 
In his reading, identity would be less defined by where who, or what we are at any given moment. But by how we respond to those states. That is the decision we make to transcend our inevitable suffering and manage to grow in spite of it. Again, it would make for a good Zen story in that it’s precisely our insufficiencies that cause transformations through a ceaseless effort to make things better than they are.

What makes this interpretation resonate? 
It’s no secret that we tend to be harsher on ourselves than on others. After all, we can’t escape the vivid memories of all the worst versions of our past selves. 
With other people, however, I found that I rather tend to focus on the trajectory they chose for their lives. What I tend to see, respect and admire in people is their story of having been to hell and gotten back out alive. In other words, I see in them the transformative spirit that drives them.

With that in mind, we should be able to put Theseus’ ship to rest. 
The thought experiment seems to be less about the rotten planks and more about the act of taking responsibility for replacing them. 
It’s about the willingness to respond to inadequacies and to let go of insufficiencies, including the ones that gradually built over time. 
Had the ship not been cared for, the vessel would’ve eventually ceased to exist due to natural decay. Granted, ships don’t have agency, which is why Theseus has to act as a proxy.

Even though in the original story the king has long passed away, we could argue that the wood was replaced in the spirit of preserving his legacy. Arguably, this wouldn’t have happened if Theseus’ deeds hadn’t had such a profound impact on Greek society. 

The replacement of the rotten planks becomes a symbol of responsible behaviour. 
The same goes for our shipbuilder. It’s not about where the planks came from. But about his efforts to turn the discarded material into something new and useful. 






Fontes: 
Noah Levin, in“Introduction to Philosophy and the Ship of Theseus.”
Noson S. Yanofsky, in "The Outer Limits of Reason: What Science, Mathematics, and Logic Cannot Tell Us" 
Jordan B. Peterson,in " 12 Rules for Life Tour"




A Cidade Devagar


Danny Doneo





Atravessaste a cidade devagar. 
Pela primeira vez, não vais trabalhar 
nem comprar um medicamento nem entregar uma carta. 

Desta vez tens sorte: 
a noite é toda tua e ela envolve-te 
e tu sentes como se estivesses nos braços da tua mãe. 

Talvez seja bom existir 
debaixo das estrelas. 

Lentamente, avanças na escuridão 
e descobres que também é bom 
ir pelas ruas e escutar os teus passos 
e sentir a noite dos que dormem 
e compreendê-los como a um único ser, 
como se descansassem da mesma existência 
no mesmo sono. 

Então avanças mais. Dobras a esquina, 
vês a pobreza insone, vês a ausência 
da tua mãe carnal. Depois, apercebes-te 
do excessivo peso do teu coração. 

E regressas.


António Gamoneda





Purpose, Goals, and Intentions







As January winds down, many people already have lost sight of the resolutions they set at the beginning of the year. Gym memberships have been abandoned. Efforts to curb screen time have dwindled. And glowing ambitions to eat better … or meditate daily … or recommit to yoga practice … or learn a new instrument or language … have dimmed.

This happens each year because it’s so much easier to forget your vision of the future than to remember it. But one of the things I love best about this work is, it’s never too late to change. It’s never too late to choose you.

Recently, I shared six simple steps you can practice so your thoughts, actions, and feelings align with the life you’re creating. Today, we’re going to talk those steps, and work through some exercises to help you remember your vision for a new future – so you don’t forget again.


Step 1. Define Your Purpose

One of the first things I learned on my own journey was the importance of living with purpose. Purpose is what gives your life meaning and direction. And purpose is dynamic. It’s uniquely personal, it’s always evolving, and it’s never-ending. It’s an overarching mission by which you set your course.

Conversely, a lack of purpose often is the main reason we lose sight of our goals – or lose our connection to a new future. Without a guiding principle or mission, how can you know if the choices you’re making are in alignment with where you want to be?

And so, before continuing with the next steps, take some time to reflect on your purpose. I find there’s no better way to do this than to sit down with myself, get quiet, and write.

Here are some prompts you can journal about:

  1. Where in my life do I naturally feel inspiration, curiosity, wonder, and motivation?
  2. Where do I struggle to find a sense of meaning or direction?
  3. Am I practicing metacognition? Am I aware of my thoughts, feelings, and behaviors?
  4. Do I have a sense of mission or vision? If not, can I remember a time when I felt connected to a higher purpose?
  5. What would be a reason for me to jump out of bed in the morning, excited for the day ahead?
  6. What would be a good mission statement for this moment in my life?

It’s powerful to give words to the things we value and we’re working toward. And taking this time to reflect on what matters most to you is a great way to choose you. You must know your purpose so well that it feels visceral – so it’s not merely words, but something that feels deeply true in an embodied sense.


Step 2. Set Achievable Goals That Support Your Purpose

Once you’ve defined your purpose, it’s important to set goals that keep you moving in that direction. This is a simple exercise in terms of approach, but it takes some time to be discerning and set goals that are simultaneously challenging – that stretch you – and achievable.

  • In your journal, write down the purpose or mission statement you arrived at in Step 1.
  • Under that statement, write down five or six realistic, achievable goals that support your mission.

For example, let’s say you’ve decided your purpose, this year, is to be healthier. That’s a broad area, so to track your progress, you need to narrow down your goals – and be specific. Your list might look something like this:

   My purpose: To be the healthiest version of myself I can be – physically, chemically, and emotionally.

    My goals:
  • Meditate every morning and evening
  • Learn about nutrition – and prepare my own healthy meals
  • Exercise at least three hours a week
  • Cut personal screen time to no more than 30 minutes a day
    • Take a break from social media
    • No screen time before bed
  • Invest more time and attention in my relationships – in person
  • Keep a journal to track my progress

Whatever your goals, it’s important they align with your purpose. That’s what keeps you on track. And, as you achieve some of the goals on your list, make sure to add new ones so you keep making progress – and you keep challenging yourself.


Step 3. Set the Intention to Make Different Choices

This may seem like an obvious step, but in all my years of doing this work, I’ve lost count of how many people are trying to reach a new future as the same person they’ve been all along. They keep making the same choices – and are somehow expecting different outcomes.

But if you’re thinking the same thoughts, feeling the same feelings, and acting out the same behaviors as your past-present self, that keeps you connected to only one place: your past. In other words, making the same choices each day will keep you in the same familiar, known life.

It makes sense, then, that if you want to connect to your new future, the only way to arrive there is as a new self. And that means making new choices. Thinking the new thoughts, feeling the new feelings, and acting out the new behaviors of your present-future self – all of this is what can lead you to a new life.

 
In your journal, spend some time exploring these questions:

  1. What are some people or situations in my current life that often cause me to go unconscious?
  2. What are the automatic thoughts and feelings that fuel my behaviors in that state?
  3. How can I prepare myself to respond differently when those challenges arise? What would my future self think, feel, or do?

When you set the intention to make different choices, it bolsters your resolve to align your thoughts, feelings, and behaviors with your purpose. So, when resistance rears up – as you know it will – you already have a plan for how you’re going to respond.

We all have that voice inside that says, 
I don’t feel like it. I’m too tired. I’m too busy. It doesn’t work anyway. I’ll start tomorrow. But with intention, you can ask yourself in those moments: Is this aligned with my purpose? Will this help me reach my next goal? What would my future self do in this moment? What choice do I need to make to become that version of me?

When you make the choice that aligns with your purpose and your vision, then in that moment, you’re choosing yourself. You’re overcoming the old programs and conditioning in your body – as well as your environment and time – and you’re investing in your new future.

Setting an intention is a way to put meaning behind what you’re doing. And when you put meaning behind what you’re doing, you’re changing your energy.


Continually Moving in the Direction of Change

Remember: nothing changes in your life until you change. You can’t see the future through the lens of the past. Your purpose points you in the direction of your new future. Your goals support that purpose – and give you measurable steps toward progress. Your intention is the fuel that helps you achieve your goals – and keeps you on purpose. And clarity about all of these helps you make the right choices as you continually move in the direction of change.

It doesn’t matter where you are in the year, or what holiday is being observed, or what personal milestone looms. It doesn’t even matter if you started off today in your automatic programs. Moment to moment, whenever you realize you’ve forgotten the new future you’re creating, you can catch yourself and bring yourself back to the present moment. You can remember. And if you keep remembering, chances are you’ll stop forgetting. You can always begin again.


Step 4. Learn to create from 3-D and 5-D

As powerful as it is to tune in to the unknown and create from the field – what we call the fifth dimension, or 5-D – there are still concrete steps you have to take, each day, here in the three-dimensional world – the plane of demonstration.

You’ll notice there’s a lot of overlap between making different choices – the third step – and doing the work in 3-D. If, in Step 1, you defined your purpose as being the healthiest version of yourself you can be physically, emotionally, and chemically, then in Step 2, you outlined goals that support that purpose:

  • Meditate every morning and evening.
  • Lose 10 pounds at a sustainable rate.
    • Prepare healthy meals and eat out less.
    • Exercise at least three hours a week.
  • Cut personal screen time to no more than 30 minutes a day.
  • Invest more time and attention in my relationships – in person.

Then, in step 3, you set the intention to make different choices – to achieve those goals. The concrete steps you must take in 3-D, then, build on the first three steps to align your actions, thoughts, and feelings with your stated purpose.

When you make those new choices, and take those concrete steps, you strengthen the signal you bring to the field when you work on your new future in the quantum, or 5-D. Here is where you tune in to the new life you’re creating. Here is where you experience how your future self will think, feel, and act as that new life unfolds.

And here is where you practice combining a clear intention with feeling the elevated emotions of your future – so you can sustain those emotions, and practice with your eyes open, when you come back to the plane of doing – and continue on in your daily life.

When you practice feeling – and sustaining – the feelings of your future on a daily basis, it takes you out of feeling the lack of not having that future. Those elevated emotions help you feel like it’s already happened – and thus, they will drive behaviors and thoughts consistent with those feelings.


Step 5. Resolve, reflect, revise, and record – every day

In a popular post last year, I wrote about the importance of beginning each day with intention and resolve – and ending each day by reflecting on how you did. These practices are about reminding yourself of your purpose, goals, and intentions throughout the day. I hope you’ll re-read that blog for an in-depth exploration of how transformative they can be.

Here, I’ll simply add a few more tools and suggestions to round out the daily exercises of resolution and reflection:

  • Work with an “accountability buddy” – someone who understands and supports your goals and will partner with you in the purposeful pursuit of their goals.
  • Try posting inspirational quotes or notes to yourself around the house – or send yourself reminders on your phone. You could try something as simple as Post-It notes on the bathroom mirror that read:
    • This is your year.
    • What would love do?
    • Are you in the feelings of your future right now?
    • You live in no time. You accomplish everything in the right state of mind and body.
    • Change yourself, change your life.
  • You might hang inspiring pictures or symbols around your home – or listen to music that elevates your emotions.

This is a really fun part of the process. Take time to experiment, play with it, and keep it engaging. Incorporate anything that helps you stay connected to that new future you’re creating and motivates you to make different choices.

Remember, you have to make time for yourself. If you don’t make time for yourself now, there will never be “enough” time later.

The third “R” in this section is about revising your model. This is so important. Just as your purpose and mission will evolve over time, so should your model of what that looks like.

  1. This means educating and informing yourself and evolving your understanding – so you can fine-tune your intentions and bring deeper meaning to your practice.
  2. I often refer to this as understanding the “what” and the “why” – so the “how” becomes easier.

Let’s use a different mission as an example here. If your stated purpose is to generate abundance, you might want to study wealthy people – and the journey they took to become successful. You’ll find, for most, it never was a linear path. The important point is to study the characteristics that made them abundant. That includes the sacrifices; the long hours; the uncompromising vision; the hard choices; how they learned from their mistakes; how they evolved over time.

All of these aspects serve as the raw materials for you to get real about the reality you’re choosing. Those people became successful on their journey – and you can learn from their experience.

Finally, the fourth “R.” As we progress in creating in alignment with our purpose, we’ll begin to see feedback in our outer reality. It may take time, but it’s important to record it when it happens.

If you’re working on improving your health and have a breakthrough in how much weight you’ve lost … or how many minutes you can run at your newest goal pace … or you notice the pain you’d suffered from for years is suddenly gone … or your lab values from your blood tests have improved … write it down.

If you’re working on creating abundance and get a promotion at work … or you receive an advance when a pitch is accepted … or you get a letter describing an accounting error accompanied by an unexpected refund … record it.

Celebrate every sign. All it takes is one breakthrough to boost your enthusiasm for the work – and your resolve to keep going.


Step 6. Make it be about your EFFORT – instead of the RESULT

When you can get through a whole meditation, workout, or meal prep, or manage your emotional state the entire day – or whatever your purpose-driven goal is – and have your behaviors match your intention … when you can go through each step and gain value from it … when you get so lost in the act, it’s no longer about the event, because the act is actually producing the event or the experience … then it’s no longer about results. It’s about your effort.

When you can finish something with great effort, there’s a celebration of you that takes place. You feel satisfied with yourself. You feel worthy of whatever it is you’re working on. And that is a very profound state in which to receive.

In other words, you no longer feel the lack of not having your new future – because you’re becoming it.

Remember: it’s never too late to change. There’s no such thing as failure; there’s only learning and evolution. It doesn’t matter if it’s the middle of February, or the day after you missed an important deadline at work, or if you’ve just completed a major cycle of growth and change and are feeling a little unclear about your next experiment.

You can always make great strides in discovering and celebrating the mystery of yourself. I hope you decide this is your year – this is your moment – to choose you.



Dr Joe Dispenza



sexta-feira, 7 de junho de 2024

The Peace of Wild Things

 






When despair for the world grows in me
and I wake in the night at the least sound
in fear of what my life and my children’s lives may be,
I go and lie down where the wood drake
rests in his beauty on the water, and the great heron feeds.
I come into the peace of wild things
who do not tax their lives with forethought
of grief. I come into the presence of still water.
And I feel above me the day-blind stars
waiting with their light. For a time
I rest in the grace of the world, and am free.


Wendell Berry
in, Tools of the Trade: Poems for new doctors



Discovering Your Purpose: The Five Types of Motivation





 I was struck by this question, which may resonate with many of you:

“What is the purpose or the mission? ‘I want to change individuals to change the whole’? … ‘I want to be a good father and husband; create an abundant life for us’? ... ‘I want to become a really happy person this year’? The big mission seems sometimes not as inspiring as the smaller ones.”


Of course, there’s no single answer that applies to even one person, let alone all of us. But if you’re also attempting to understand or define your purpose or mission, there is something that can help you in your discernment – and that’s what I refer to as the five types of motivation.


1. Purpose Motivation

The first, or highest, form of motivation is purpose motivation. We also can refer to this as “mission” or “duty” motivation. Just as the name suggests, this is when you’re inspired by a higher calling; a sense of purpose that drives you toward a vision – a vision bigger than you alone.

When you’re purpose-driven, you’re committed to serving others or changing the world in some way. It’s when you have a vocation that considers more of the whole. You want to impact as many people as possible – and that’s what makes purpose motivation the most selfless form of motivation. Being in service to others is what gets you out of bed in the morning.

I think some people might struggle with what it means to have a higher purpose – because they think it must mean something grandiose or out of reach. All of us can summon the image of people in history who clearly were motivated by a grand vision for what the world could be. Just imagine some of the greatest innovators, philosophers, and activists – and you’re picturing people who were motivated by a mission.

That doesn’t mean, though, that you have to be operating on a global scale. It simply means you see a possibility for a better world – and that’s what motivates you.

When you’re in service to a mission or a purpose, you’re committed to changing the world for the better. And that can happen on the scale of your world – your family; the culture at your company; your community.


2. Personal Conviction Motivation

Right under purpose or duty motivation is personal conviction motivation. 
This is when you say, “I’m going to do this – because I said I was going to do it.” 
If you’re operating under personal conviction, you’re what’s known as a “self-starter.” You’re disciplined and entrepreneurial in your efforts.

Personal conviction motivation also is a high form of motivation – but not the highest form. It’s possible to be motivated or driven through personal conviction or discipline – but without having a sense of higher purpose.

However, it makes sense that people who have purpose motivation inherently have personal conviction. Their principles are in alignment with their purpose – because they have a reason to get up every day.

In other words, when you have a mission; a vision; a purpose ... you naturally also have personal conviction.


3. Ethics Motivation

The next form of motivation is ethics motivation – or “morality-based” motivation. As you might guess from its position halfway through the list, this is neither the highest nor lowest form of motivation; it’s sort of the middle of the road.

In short, ethics motivation is based on polarity: 
Good or bad. Right or wrong. Success or failure. Sin or repentance. 
A lot of models and doctrines are based on this approach to the world. It can be a short-sighted form of motivation; as anything that polarizes us involves a kind of judgment that narrows our view – and our influence. So, while you might be guided by a strong sense of ethics, you might be missing a sense of personal conviction – or higher purpose.

But we know from our research that people who have purpose motivation and are personally convicted also have a great sense of ethics and morality. When we’re guided by something bigger than we are, that aspect falls right in into place.


4. Self-Aggrandizement Motivation

The next kind of motivation is called self-aggrandizement or “ego-centered” motivation. 
This is pretty straightforward. If you’re driven by acclaim, recognition, status, or popularity, you’re motivated by self-aggrandizement.

By now, you’ve figured out there’s a hierarchy at work here. As we go down the list, from one through five, the field of vision becomes narrower ... and the form of motivation becomes more self-centered.

As so we know, then, this is not a very high form of motivation. And any gains made within its structure tend not to last, in terms of satisfaction and impact.

And yet: people who have purpose motivation, personal conviction, and a strong sense of ethics tend to naturally receive recognition. You can think of it as an unintended “side-effect” of those higher forms of motivation.


5. Money Motivation

This probably needs the least amount of explanation. Money motivation is the lowest – and most selfish – form of motivation. People who are motivated solely by financial gain will always take care of their own needs first.

You’ve no doubt encountered someone who was money-motivated – and you probably knew it within moments of meeting them.

Now, plenty of people in this work are working on creating abundance. And if that’s one of your goals, there’s nothing wrong with that. What I’m talking about is what inspires you – what principles guide your thoughts, feelings, and behaviors. The question becomes: Why are you driven to be abundant?

And – as the pattern described above shows with other forms of motivation – if you’re motivated by money alone, you may generate wealth, but your life probably will lack deeper meaning beyond that. Conversely, we know that if you have a strong sense of purpose ... a deep personal conviction ... a strong sense of ethics ... and if you’ve achieved some amount of recognition ... then money naturally follows.


Broadening Your View

As with every other aspect of this work, the opportunity in understanding the five types of motivation is increasing your self-awareness – so you can make informed choices and commitments within your practice. This isn’t about judgment or shame. It doesn’t matter where you place your own current level of motivation within the hierarchy; it matters that you make the unconscious conscious – so you can decide who you want to be.

What I’ve seen, time and again, is people who come into this work determined to create great wealth. Or, they might be driven by a desire for fame and status – or what feels like a truly defining sense of morality. And they might indeed achieve the goals they set within those values.

But what inevitably happens – once they receive the wealth, the fame, or the vindication – is, they come up against a feeling of emptiness. They realize they want to be part of something greater – otherwise, what is this all for?

And that is a great moment, because it means they’re ready to broaden their view of the world – and to make more of a contribution to others.


Knowing By Heart

Finally, I’ll share with you something I told the participants at our most recent retreat. 
Your own practice can be your purpose.

You might decide to join a Coherence Healing Group and commit your time and energy to giving life to another’s life. That mission would be changing a part of the world. You might decide to sit down with yourself every morning, determined to get up from your meditation as a different person – one who is going to practice with your eyes open. One who is going to change the world through love, presence, and kindness. That’s also being an example for the world – and it’s a selfless purpose.

You might set the intention to catch yourself in moments of reactivity and ask yourself: 
“What would love do?” and then change your response, allowing you to be more present for your family and loved ones – and an example for your children. They, in turn, might change others’ lives through their own practice, as they follow the example you’ve modeled for them.

Every time you show up in this way, you’re evolving our community – and you’re changing the world.

It’s important to ask yourself where you are on your path – and what brings the most meaning to your life. And, when you finally discover your calling, it won’t just be something you think about in your mind; it will become visceral for you. It won’t be something you identify through thought or language alone; it will resonate in mind, body, heart, and soul.

In other words, you may define it in your head, but more important: you’ll know it in your heart. 
And that’s my wish for you.



Dr Joe Dispenza



segunda-feira, 3 de junho de 2024

How Writing Helps Anxiety








Writing's a brilliant way of helping to speed up recovery from anxiety. 
Studies show that writing acts as a shock absorber against excessive thinking, which is something we all do when we’re anxious. 


Writing, instead of thinking, helps to get problems out of the mind and onto paper. 
This gives us a better perspective and helps us to find solutions. 
It also gives us reassurance that we can manage day-to-day problems. 
When you look back through your journal entries of even a few days ago, you will see that you got through a difficult period and this will give you the courage to continue. 

You can buy a special notebook you’ll enjoy writing in but keep it somewhere safe as you don’t want anyone else to be reading what you’ve written. It’s for your eyes only. 




There is one type of writing technique I want to show you that needs more of an introduction and explanation and that’s Non-dominant writing. 

Non-dominant writing is designed to help you access those parts of yourself you may have ignored for years. When we’re anxious we are not in tune with the wise and sometimes vulnerable part we keep hidden inside. 


However, this wise and sensitive part of us is full of intelligence on how to make our lives better. As we get older we tend to push away these instincts and, in the process, we push away our creativity, which is fundamental to our well-being. We all have the answers to the challenges that face us and it’s a case of reuniting with that hidden part of us when we’re struggling with life’s problems to help us get back on our feet. 

Non-dominant hand writing is done with the hand you do not write with. 

If you write with your right hand, your non-dominant hand is the left, and if you write with your left hand, your non- dominant hand is the right. 
Your non-dominant hand is connected to your intuition and emotion whereas your dominant hand is connected to your conscious, thinking side. 

Once you pick up a pen in your non-dominant hand you’re automatically writing from a child-like standpoint. It’s hard to get the words to look right and even holding the pen can feel awkward. However, the words you write are straight from the heart and can help you access your true feelings about something when you are unaware of these. 

Once you begin writing with your non-dominant hand you may be surprised at the words falling on the page. You may become frightened at the strength of the feelings that are released because they’ve probably been buried for some time. But the amazing thing is that you can then use your dominant hand to support your more vulnerable self. This activity works best when you use two pages of your journal. So if you are right-handed you write with your left hand on the left-hand page of your journal and respond with your right hand on the right-hand page of the journal and vice versa if you’re left-handed. 

Here’s a quick example: 


Non-dominant hand: I feel sad today. 

Dominant hand: Why do you feel sad?

Non-dominant hand: Because I’m lonely and alone.

Dominant hand: You’re not alone, it just feels like that.

Non-dominant hand: But there’s no one here. 

Dominant hand: Yes, but only for now. And  I’m here for you.  I’ll be here every day from now on. 

Non-dominant hand: Do you promise?

Dominant hand: Yes I promise. 


As simplistic as this looks, it really works. 

While you explore yourself through non-dominant writing you may find that the language you use with the different hands seems to come from two separate parts of you. And it does! 
One is expressing feelings whilst the other is expressing logic. 
It helps to bring you closer to yourself and it works very quickly. 

This activity is used in the Beat Anxiety Program to help you find things that you can focus on and help break through the chaos of anxiety.

You may find that by doing this activity regularly your life may become simpler. 
What’s exciting is how we recognize that our needs are actually very simple. 
We don’t need to conquer the world; all we really want is to feel peaceful. 



Alexandra Massey