quinta-feira, 19 de novembro de 2026

The Wound-Dresser

 

Delih Ayat






1

An old man bending I come among new faces,
Years looking backward resuming in answer to children,
Come tell us old man, as from young men and maidens that love me,
(Arous’d and angry, I’d thought to beat the alarum, and urge relentless war,
But soon my fingers fail’d me, my face droop’d and I resign’d myself,
To sit by the wounded and soothe them, or silently watch the dead;)
Years hence of these scenes, of these furious passions, these chances,
Of unsurpass’d heroes, (was one side so brave? the other was equally brave;)
Now be witness again, paint the mightiest armies of earth,
Of those armies so rapid so wondrous what saw you to tell us?
What stays with you latest and deepest? of curious panics,
Of hard-fought engagements or sieges tremendous what deepest remains?


2

O maidens and young men I love and that love me,
What you ask of my days those the strangest and sudden your talking recalls,
Soldier alert I arrive after a long march cover’d with sweat and dust,
In the nick of time I come, plunge in the fight, loudly shout in the rush of successful charge,
Enter the captur’d works—yet lo, like a swift running river they fade,
Pass and are gone they fade—I dwell not on soldiers’ perils or soldiers’ joys,
(Both I remember well—many of the hardships, few the joys, yet I was content.)

But in silence, in dreams’ projections,
While the world of gain and appearance and mirth goes on,
So soon what is over forgotten, and waves wash the imprints off the sand,
With hinged knees returning I enter the doors, (while for you up there,
Whoever you are, follow without noise and be of strong heart.)

Bearing the bandages, water and sponge,
Straight and swift to my wounded I go,
Where they lie on the ground after the battle brought in,
Where their priceless blood reddens the grass, the ground,
Or to the rows of the hospital tent, or under the roof’d hospital,
To the long rows of cots up and down each side I return,
To each and all one after another I draw near, not one do I miss,
An attendant follows holding a tray, he carries a refuse pail,
Soon to be fill’d with clotted rags and blood, emptied, and fill’d again.

I onward go, I stop,
With hinged knees and steady hand to dress wounds,
I am firm with each, the pangs are sharp yet unavoidable,
One turns to me his appealing eyes—poor boy! I never knew you,
Yet I think I could not refuse this moment to die for you, if that would save you.


3

On, on I go, (open doors of time! open hospital doors!)
The crush’d head I dress, (poor crazed hand tear not the bandage away,)
The neck of the cavalry-man with the bullet through and through I examine,
Hard the breathing rattles, quite glazed already the eye, yet life struggles hard,
(Come sweet death! be persuaded O beautiful death!
In mercy come quickly.)

From the stump of the arm, the amputated hand,
I undo the clotted lint, remove the slough, wash off the matter and blood,
Back on his pillow the soldier bends with curv’d neck and side falling head,
His eyes are closed, his face is pale, he dares not look on the bloody stump,
And has not yet look’d on it.

I dress a wound in the side, deep, deep,
But a day or two more, for see the frame all wasted and sinking,
And the yellow-blue countenance see.

I dress the perforated shoulder, the foot with the bullet-wound,
Cleanse the one with a gnawing and putrid gangrene, so sickening, so offensive,
While the attendant stands behind aside me holding the tray and pail.
 
I am faithful, I do not give out,
The fractur’d thigh, the knee, the wound in the abdomen,
These and more I dress with impassive hand, (yet deep in my breast a fire, a burning flame.)


4

Thus in silence in dreams’ projections,
Returning, resuming, I thread my way through the hospitals,
The hurt and wounded I pacify with soothing hand,
I sit by the restless all the dark night, some are so young,
Some suffer so much, I recall the experience sweet and sad,
(Many a soldier’s loving arms about this neck have cross’d and rested,
Many a soldier’s kiss dwells on these bearded lips.)




 Walt Whitman



...................... slavery was not a European invention


    





Belgian essayist, historian and journalist David Van Reybrouck has taken a close look at Belgian and Dutch colonialism in two major works: 
“Congo, the epic history of a people”, and 
“Revolusi, Indonesia and the birth of the modern world”. 

He talks about the recent increase in Western awareness of colonial violence, and describes its symbolic limits. In his view, 

"we struggle against the symbols of past injustices while accepting the structures of present injustices”.


In his acclaimed history book Congo: 
The Epic History of a People, Belgian author and historian David Van Reybrouck makes the historical point that,
 Slavery was not a European invention—it was a widespread, pre-existing institution in Central Africa, as well as in the Arab world and ancient civilizations, long before explorers arrived at the mouth of the Congo River in the late 15th century.

However, Van Reybrouck emphasizes that Europeans fundamentally transformed the nature, scale, and brutality of the practice. He highlights several critical distinctions between pre-colonial African slavery and the European transatlantic slave trade:
• Domestic vs. Industrial Scale. Before European contact, slavery in the Kingdom of Kongo and surrounding regions was primarily domestic, small-scale, and tied to war captives, judicial punishment, or debt. European demand for labor on American plantations turned human beings into a mass-market global commodity. 
• Social Integration vs. Chattel Slavery. In traditional Central African societies, enslaved people often retained certain rights, could marry into the local community, and their children were frequently born free. The European system introduced chattel slavery—permanent, hereditary bondage stripped of legal personhood. 
• Destabilization of African Kingdoms. Van Reybrouck details how the insatiable European appetite for captives—fueled by firearms and manufactured goods—corrupted local economies and political structures. Even rulers who initially tried to regulate or halt the trade, such as King Afonso I of Kongo (Nzinga Mbemba), found their kingdoms torn apart by internal slave raiding driven by European coastal demand. 
• The East African / Arab Slave Trade. Van Reybrouck also documents the devastating 19th-century Arab-Swahili slave and ivory trade led by figures like Tippu Tip in eastern Congo, showing how Central Africa was ravaged from both the Atlantic and Indian Ocean coasts before King Leopold II imposed his own brutal regime of forced labor.
Van Reybrouck’s broader argument is not meant to excuse European colonialism, but to present a nuanced, non-eurocentric history in which African societies are understood with their own pre-existing complexities—while making clear that European capitalism industrialized and racialized slavery to an unprecedented degree.

Van Reybrouck discuss the arrival of explorers and missionaries in the Kingdom of Kongo in the late 15th century, as well as the role of local African elites (such as King Afonso I / Nzinga Mbemba) as intermediaries in the slave trade. 
About the underexplored complexity of African elites involvement, he stated:
"In fact, slavery already existed in Africa before the arrival of the explorers, just as on every continent. It wasn't a European invention. What was a European invention the abolition of slavery. Yes, Europeans trafficked slaves on an incredible scale for three and a half centuries. But the abolitionist movement is also a European invention. That is why I don't really like this kind of hatred for everything European."

• Scale and Economic Paralysis. Van Reybrouck emphasized that while slavery predated European contact, Europeans massively accelerated and multiplied the number of enslaved people. He compared past economic arguments used to defend slavery ("without slaves, the economy will collapse") to modern arguments resisting climate action ("it will mean the end of our business"). 
 
• Nuance in Colonial History. Discussing his books Congo and Revolusi, he argued against reducing colonial history to "constant self-flagellation" or purely symbolic gestures (like renaming streets or tearing down statues) while ignoring structural issues like climate change, which he frames as a form of contemporary colonialism. 
 
• Portuguese and Chinese Diplomacy. He noted that early Portuguese expansion relied on building close ties between European and local elites—a strategy he sees mirrored in China's modern diplomatic and economic approach in Africa. 
 
• Democratic Reform. Drawing from his book Against Elections, he advocated for complementing traditional elections with citizens' assemblies selected by lottery (sortition) to overcome electoral paralysis and improve representation.




Interviewed by Christine Chaumeau:
 

What do Belgium and the Netherlands have in common regarding colonization, and what distinguishes them?

In colonizing the Congo, King Leopold II was directly inspired by the Dutch kings William I and II, especially with regard to the role of local aristocracies. Colonizing was a costly affair, so the most effective way was to rely on the local elites, making agreements with them. In the Dutch East Indies (now Indonesia), this led to excesses by the Javanese aristocracy. Indeed, in the early 19th century, the Netherlands brought a number of crops: coffee, indigo, quinine. The people had to provide these crops. The local aristocracy received bonuses when the crops were good. The bonus was such that it led to exactions.

In both cases, it was colonialism stemming from capitalism, in other words exploitation was the basis of the enterprise. But there is a great distinction between the two. In the case of the Dutch occupied Indies, it was agricultural exploitation. In the Congo of Leopold II, it was industrial and mining colonization. It began with rubber and then extended to copper, with the consequence in the Belgian Congo that exploitation was concentrated in the south, in the Katanga region. Dutch colonization extended over the whole territory. In that case, there was a clearer colonial presence over a larger territory, very much focused on agriculture.

In terms of violence, the Belgians were worse in colonization and the Dutch in decolonization. In Indonesia, from the middle of the 19th century, there were vaccination campaigns; from 1900, there was education for Indonesians; from 1910, there was a first generation of doctors trained by the Dutch. In the Belgian Congo, in 1960 there were only 16 or 17 graduates. Until the 1950s, physical punishment was still de rigueur. In the Dutch Indies, the colonists were under the illusion that the Javanese people were gentle. There were a few "bad apples", inspired by Islam, nationalism and Marxism. These troublesome personalities were physically removed to an internment camp in Papua, in the bush. The vast majority of Dutch people are completely unaware of the existence of this veritable gulag, in which the prisoners had to build their own penal residence and live there under very difficult conditions.



Today, is the relationship to this colonial past different in "small countries" like Belgium and the Netherlands compared with France or Great Britain?

For You Gov [polling and market research company], British researchers sought to find out which country was the most proud of its colonial past. To their surprise, the Netherlands won the contest, and by far. In 2019, 50% of Dutch people said they were proud of the colonial past; 26% hoped for a new overseas project; and only 6% had a negative view. This is incredible. It shows how much the memory of the colonial past has been reduced in the Netherlands. The national discourse, the memory, was dictated by the 120,000 veterans, the 300,000 colonists, the Indo-Europeans who returned. The national discourse was formed by those who were forced to leave - in total, 450,000 people. As with Algeria and France, there was the equivalent of the Harkis, people who came from the Moluccas, conscripted into the colonial army. On the other hand, very few Indonesians settled in the Netherlands after Indonesia's independence. In addition, the hours of history teaching have been reduced in high school studies. This really leads to a blindness, a historical illiteracy.

Things have changed recently...

The last few years have seen a colossal acceleration in the Dutch collective memory. Several factors have contributed to this: the condemnation of the State by the courts, the studies of Swiss-Dutch historian Rémy Limpach, the apology of the King in 2020 and that of the Prime Minister in 2022, and finally the recent report "Independence, decolonization, violence and war in Indonesia 1945-1950" - dates of the end of the colonial period in Indonesia.

This very large report condemns what happened. Certainly, the fact that this research avoids the term war crime has been criticized as a weakness. On the contrary, in my opinion, the use of "extreme violence" allows for a broader definition not to be limited to the definition of war crimes at the time. It has been established that this was systemic violence, that it was in the military structures that this form of violence was used, with the full knowledge of the military and political authorities.

Until a few years ago, around 2013-2014, there was only a small room called "The Netherlands Overseas" out of 60 exhibition rooms at the Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam. I feel that this is a bit inadequate for a country that has been active for three centuries on three continents. Since then, the museum has done an exhibition on the Indonesian revolution. And the collections have been reorganized. We are really seeing a major acceleration in the way we deal with the colonial past.

I can assure you that I have seen first-hand, for the first time in my life, how a collective memory can evolve. Along with my book, there have also been documentaries broadcast as well as a theatrical tour on the subject. I spoke in front of about 25,000 people. In the room, there were remarks such as "Why didn't we know?", and "I am ashamed, what should I do about it?”


Are both sides of the story being told?

In Belgium, at this very moment, the Congo Commission is meeting in Parliament. In the preparatory work, there have been historians, people from the diaspora, from both sides. There is a real willingness to listen and to exchange. This is absolutely essential.

There is a big difference between the situation in the Netherlands and in Belgium. In Belgium, there are many Congolese, Burundians and Rwandans, more than there are Indonesians in the Netherlands. Congolese, Burundians and Rwandans arrived after the genocide [in Rwanda] in 1994. They are the children of the genocide. They are in their 20s and 30s and are some of the biggest activists. They live the reality of urban or suburban life in a post-colonial Belgium where discrimination is still present. So this both sides discussion has taken place. The preparatory work for the Congo Commission was interesting, rich and nourishing. The Parliament is now talking about it.


And in the Netherlands?

There is a big difference. In the Netherlands, the King and the Prime Minister apologized in 2020 and 2022 respectively for the violence committed during decolonization in Indonesia in 1945-1949. Nothing was said about the 350 years before that, while the Belgian king expressed his deepest regret about the entire colonial era, including the time of his great-great-uncle Leopold II. The Netherlands has taken an important step, but let's not think that everything was smooth sailing before the war of independence began in 1945. There was violence for 350 years. So the difference between the two countries is very clear.


In the Netherlands, do we hear the stories from Indonesia?

We are making an effort. In the exhibition at the Rijkmuseum, two of the curators were Indonesians. But they were criticized. One of them published a "carte blanche", an opinion piece in NRC, the leading Dutch newspaper. I see that Indonesians are given a voice as long as they say what we want to hear from them.

A parallel can be drawn with the debate about what happened at the Documenta [contemporary art exhibition that takes place every five years in Germany] this year, where there were Indonesian curators. When I was in Germany to promote my book, I was constantly asked why there was so much anti-Semitism in Indonesia. I think there are more anti-Semites in Germany than in Indonesia, but Documenta was accused of being anti-Semitic. I went there, I met the Indonesian curators, young and old, open to the world. I think that the Documenta they made is the most important in the history of this event. For the first time, a collective from the South was given the floor. This Indonesian collective opened the programme by inviting artists from the South. In both cases, at the Rijksmuseum and at the Documenta, I notice that the point of view of the Indonesians was not taken into account.


So we are not ready to listen to these voices?

This is the beginning of a dialogue that should be global, and it is difficult as it creates tensions. There are European sensitivities that have not been well perceived. Sensitivity about what happened to the Indo-Dutch [targets of abuse by the Indonesians during the War of Independence] and anti-Semitism. In fact, we invite people from the other side of the world while thinking that they have a framework of thought, historical and moral references identical to ours. And as soon as they make a faux-pas against the European moral perceptions, they are disqualified.

That said, in the historical research conducted by the Royal Netherlands Institute for Southeast Asian and Caribbean Studies (KITLV), the Netherlands Institute for Military History and the Institute for War, Holocaust and Genocide Studies (NIOD) on the War of Independence in the Netherlands, Indonesian historians have had a less controversial role. This is probably because science works differently from the art world.


You say you were surprised by the attitude of young Indonesians, who are indifferent to the colonial past. This makes them different from young Congolese. Why do populations affected by colonization react differently?

Indonesia is doing better than the Congo. Indonesia is an emerging economy; the Congo is a failed state. In Indonesia, the past is very much in the past, and it is used in a more playful way - for example, cafes where hipsters use references to the colonial past. Even the colonial spelling is reused. But I am increasingly wondering if it will stay that way, especially with the brutal way global warming is going to be felt. Jakarta, the Indonesian capital, is partly flooded. Will the colonial reference remain playful? In my opinion, there would be fertile ground to plant an anti-colonial discourse. If your crop is not like it used to be, if drought hits your family, if your house is flooded, it is the fault of the Westerners. They have exploited us in the past, they are still exploiting us.


The report of the Belgian commission on the colonial past advocates payment of reparations. What do you think about this? How do you think this past can be repaired?

Belgium could recognize the suffering that took place, the discrimination and the effects of racism from which "Afropeans" still suffer, to use the expression popularized by the novelist Léonora Miano. The word recognition seems to me to be essential here. The report of the Belgian experts came up with a whole series of interesting forms of reparation: the restitution of objects, which is fully underway - even if some objects will perhaps remain in Belgium, their property will be Congolese - or the creation of a House for Congolese culture in Brussels. In my opinion, this is a legitimate demand.



What would such a place allow in terms of reparations for the colonial past?

In the diaspora, there is a lot of creativity and energy. It would allow for the professional structuring of this artistic milieu with the means of the State. The State would subsidize. One speaks thus about a real recognition. At the same time, I know that there is a whole discussion on the monuments, the street names. This point is important, but what strikes me is that we work so much on historical colonialism that we tend to forget the colonization of the present and the future. And a Belgian mayor who has removed all the problematic statues and changed the street names, who has adapted the school books but has done nothing against global warming as his municipality continues to use fossil energy, such a mayor has done less against colonialism than one who ensures his municipality will be heated with renewable energy by 2040. In Brussels, the hottest parts of the city are the poorest parts, where the migrants live. The parts where the air is most polluted are the districts where the descendants of people from the former colonies live. You can change a statue or a street name somewhere in a nice residential area, but it won't change anything in relation to this so-called rotten neighbourhood.

I don't quite understand how the fight for decolonization can be separated from the fight against global warming. Focusing only on historical colonialism without seeing the future seems to me problematic. We are fighting against the symbols of past injustices while accepting the structures of present injustices! We can imagine a Belgium where all the names of streets and squares have be cleaned up but where a young dentist has difficulty finding a place in a practice because she is of Congolese origin, where a family has difficulty finding a place to live because they are of African descent. What is the point of having good school books that respect African history if, at the same time, a Burundian family cannot find suitable housing?


Is the restitution of objects also symbolic?

It is not for me to say. It is up to the Beninese, Congolese, Burundians to say "yes, indeed this belongs to us". Let's not be paternalistic. Let's not say: you have to take these objects back. It is not for us to say that, when most Congolese are in an economy of survival. They don't have the luxury of dealing with masks stolen at the end of the 19th century. That's not to say that we shouldn't look at this kind of challenge - I think it's important that a young Congolese person has the chance to see in their own capital city artistic and cultural objects that are important to their culture. That seems good to me. But I say if that's all you do, you miss the point.


What role can the judiciary play in the recognition of colonial facts?

It was a Dutch judge who opened the eyes of the Dutch. The judge condemned the state to compensate the widows of the Rawagede massacre in December 1947 [431 men killed by Dutch soldiers on the island of Java]. You can see the gigantic importance of this legal work. At the same time, I found it strange that elderly people had to take action in court. Should the descendants of all the victims of the Dutch atrocities go to court? At some point, I think the Dutch state should show some recognition, that all those who can prove their family connection to those who died in the systemic violence are important. Perhaps there should be some form of general justice that prevents older people from having to go to court.


What do you think about calling colonization a crime against humanity, as French President Emmanuel Macron did in 2017 in Algeria?

Of course, Macron is right when he talks about colonization as a crime against humanity.

It's obvious that the past still hurts. It is obvious that the colonial wound has not healed and that every form of reparation, of reconciliation that can unite humanity is important, because in the face of today's challenges, we will have to resolve our differences. We will need to fight global warming together. We will need to fight shoulder to shoulder.

Acknowledging the wrongs of the past is essential, of course. Colonialism, even in its most humanistic form, has always been exploitation. This is the hard core of colonialism. The colonialism of the 19th and 20th centuries is a consequence of the global capitalism led by the West since the 15th century.

But let us beware of excuses, because they maintain the circle of revenge. There is always a winner and a loser. The American Marshall Rosenberg, creator in the 1960s of non-violent communication, says it clearly: asking for an apology changes the hierarchy but keeps the spirit of revenge. It is not a true reparation, not a true reconciliation. On the other hand, I think that the work of Desmond Tutu in South Africa, with the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, has been extremely important. In this sense, I am very happy that the Congo Commission in the Belgian Parliament is not only working on truth but on reconciliation. The term reconciliation is important and reconciliation can take many forms. There are several mechanisms to promote reconciliation. For the moment, they seem to me to be lacking. We talk about apologies, reparations, statues. Let's broaden the range of possible forms of reparations.



What do you have in mind?

I think the proposals of the commission of Belgian experts were really rich. For example, this project of a Congolese cultural centre in Brussels is a simple and very reasonable thing. We can imagine scholarships for Congolese students, or conversely the possibility for Belgian students to spend some time in Africa. Let's really talk about partnerships. Let's have people who say to themselves: "it's not me, it's not you, we are the children of history, we didn't make this history, unfortunately we can't change it anymore, and it's up to us to show that there are ways to overcome this history and to get out of the logic of revenge”.

In justice, we are witnessing the emergence of restorative justice which organizes an encounter between the victim and the person who caused them harm. For me, there is a wealth of thought and practice in this type of justice. Let's imagine that some of the richness, the wisdom of this restorative justice, today essentially practiced in person-to-person situations, is injected when we talk about post-colonial justice. There is much to be gained from this. If we want to talk to each other as adults, we will have to be inspired by this restorative justice.


What would this allow?

It allows you to go further, to really move forward and overcome the misdeeds of the past. It allows us to digest the past, to sublimate the past, to find a certain form of "closure". There is an urgency. Otherwise, we are going to remain countries and peoples in strained relations, at a time when the North Pole is disappearing, species are disappearing, droughts are increasing and the Earth is becoming unliveable. So should we do nothing because we remain frozen in our past?



DAVID VAN REYBROUCK 
in, Fondation Hirondelle Justice Info



segunda-feira, 16 de novembro de 2026

“Hope” is the thing with feathers


StockCake





 “Hope” is the thing with feathers -
That perches in the soul -
And sings the tune without the words -
And never stops — at all -

And sweetest — in the Gale — is heard -
And sore must be the storm -
That could abash the little Bird
That kept so many warm -

I’ve heard it in the chillest land -
And on the strangest Sea -
Yet — never — in Extremity,
It asked a crumb — of me.



Emily Dickinson





The Painful Truth About Losing Friends


Andrey Kiselev






 Why Carl Jung Warned That 
Some People Were Never 
Who You Thought They Were

The psychology of fake friendships, hidden betrayal, and the unconscious patterns that keep you attached to people who don't truly value you—and how to finally break free.




There is a particular kind of heartbreak that comes from losing a friend.
It is not always dramatic. There may be no argument, no betrayal you can point to, no final conversation in which someone admits they no longer care.

Sometimes, it happens quietly.

The messages become shorter. The invitations disappear. The person who once knew everything about your life gradually becomes a stranger. You notice that you are always the one reaching out, always the one remembering birthdays, always the one trying to keep something alive that seems to have stopped breathing on the other side.

And then comes the question:

Did I actually lose a friend, or did I finally discover that I never had one?

That question hurts because it forces you to reconsider more than a relationship. 
It forces you to reconsider your judgment, your memories, and perhaps even your understanding of yourself.

You remember the conversations, the laughter, the promises, and the moments when you genuinely believed someone was there for you.
Were those moments real?
Perhaps some were. Perhaps others meant something entirely different to the person sitting across from you.

Carl Jung, the Swiss psychiatrist who explored the unconscious, projection, and the hidden dimensions of personality, offers a powerful lens through which to understand this experience.
One of his most important psychological insights was that we do not always see people as they are. 
We often see them through the unconscious material we bring into relationships: our desires, fears, expectations, and unresolved emotional needs.

In other words, sometimes we fall in love with a friendship that exists partly in our imagination.

And the most painful moment is not necessarily when the friendship ends.
It is when the illusion ends.



1. You May Have Been Attached to Who You Thought They Were
Think about someone you once considered a close friend.
Perhaps you believed they were loyal, understanding, generous, or emotionally available.

You trusted them with personal information. You defended them when others questioned their character. You interpreted their absence as busyness and their indifference as temporary exhaustion.

Whenever their behavior disappointed you, you found an explanation.
They are going through something.
They have a lot on their plate.
They probably didn’t mean it.

You kept giving their behavior the benefit of the doubt because accepting the alternative would have meant questioning the entire relationship.

This is where Jung’s concept of projection becomes relevant.
Projection occurs when we unconsciously attribute our own feelings, expectations, or qualities to another person.
  • We may see someone as exceptionally loyal because loyalty is one of our deepest values. 
  • We may interpret occasional kindness as evidence of profound emotional connection because we desperately want to feel understood.

We are not necessarily seeing the person clearly.
We are seeing them through the lens of what we hope they represent.

Psychologically, this can create a painful gap between the person we know and the person we imagine.
And the longer we maintain that image, the harder it becomes to let go.

Here is the uncomfortable truth:
Sometimes, you are not grieving the person you lost. You are grieving the person you believed you had.

That distinction changes everything.
Because you cannot build a healthy friendship with someone’s potential, imagined intentions, or occasional demonstrations of affection.
You can only build it with the person who consistently shows up.


2. The Friendship May Have Been Real, but the Investment Was Never Equal
Not every disappointing friendship was fake.
This is an important distinction.

Two people can genuinely enjoy each other’s company while assigning completely different meanings to the relationship.
  • To one person, the friendship may represent emotional security, loyalty, and lifelong connection.
  • To the other, it may simply represent convenience, entertainment, shared interests, or a pleasant way to spend time.
Neither person necessarily intended to deceive the other.
But the imbalance can still become devastating.

Imagine Sarah and Emily.
Sarah remembers Emily’s problems, checks on her during difficult weeks, celebrates her successes, and makes time whenever Emily needs support.
Emily appreciates Sarah. She enjoys their conversations and genuinely likes spending time together.

But when Sarah experiences a personal crisis, Emily is rarely available.
Sarah initially makes excuses.
Then she becomes disappointed.
Eventually, she realizes that the relationship has always depended more heavily on her emotional investment.

This is what makes one-sided friendships so difficult to recognize: 
they can contain genuine affection without genuine reciprocity.

Research on close relationships consistently emphasizes the importance of responsiveness, trust, mutual support, and perceived fairness.
A friendship does not need perfectly equal contributions every day. Life circumstances change. Sometimes one person gives more.

But over time, both people should feel that their presence matters.
A friendship becomes exhausting when one person is responsible for keeping it alive.
And if you have to repeatedly convince someone to care about your presence, it may be time to reconsider how much of yourself you are investing.


3. You Keep Making Excuses Because Losing Them Feels Worse Than Losing Yourself
Why do intelligent, emotionally aware people sometimes remain in relationships that repeatedly disappoint them?
Because understanding someone’s behavior is not the same as being willing to accept its consequences.

You may know that a friend is unreliable.
You may recognize that they contact you only when they need something.
You may even notice that you feel emotionally smaller after spending time with them.

Yet you continue.
Why?

Because the human mind does not evaluate relationships through logic alone.
Attachment, familiarity, emotional investment, and fear of rejection all influence our decisions.

Psychological research on attachment suggests that earlier relational experiences can shape how people respond to closeness, distance, and perceived abandonment.
For someone who fears rejection, a friend’s withdrawal may trigger an intense desire to restore connection.

Instead of asking, 
“Is this relationship healthy for me?” 
they begin asking, 
“What can I do to make this person stay?”

That is a dangerous psychological shift.
You begin negotiating against your own needs.
You become less honest about your feelings. You accept behavior that once would have disappointed you. You lower your expectations and call it maturity.

Eventually, you may become so focused on preserving the friendship that you forget to examine whether it is preserving you.

Read that again.

You can become so afraid of losing someone that you slowly lose the person you were before you met them.
And that is a price no friendship should demand.


4. Jung’s Shadow: Sometimes What We Refuse to See Is What We Need to Understand
Jung’s concept of the shadow refers to aspects of ourselves that we do not fully recognize or accept.
These may include anger, envy, insecurity, selfishness, fear, or desires that conflict with our preferred self-image.

The shadow is not simply the evil part of a person. It includes neglected and unacknowledged aspects of the personality.
This concept also offers a challenging way to examine failed friendships.

When someone disappoints us, it is tempting to focus entirely on their shortcomings.
They were selfish.
They were dishonest.
They were emotionally unavailable.

Sometimes those descriptions are accurate.
But another question deserves attention:

What did I refuse to acknowledge because I wanted this friendship to work?

  1. Perhaps you noticed the warning signs but dismissed them.
  2. Perhaps you confused being needed with being valued.
  3. Perhaps you tolerated disrespect because you wanted to be seen as understanding, forgiving, or easy to get along with.
  4. Perhaps you were afraid that setting boundaries would expose how little the other person was willing to give.

This is not an invitation to blame yourself for someone else’s behavior.
You are not responsible for another person’s dishonesty or lack of empathy.
But you are responsible for learning from what the experience reveals about your own boundaries.

The purpose of self-examination is not to punish yourself.
It is to prevent the same emotional pattern from repeating.

Jung’s broader work on individuation—the process of becoming more psychologically integrated and less governed by unconscious expectations—reminds us that personal growth requires facing truths we would rather avoid.

Sometimes the most important question after losing a friend is not:
“Why did they treat me this way?”

It is:

“Why did I keep accepting a relationship that made me feel this way?”



5. Some People Only Like You When You Play the Role They Need
This is one of the most uncomfortable truths about human relationships.

Some people do not necessarily love who you are.
They love what you provide.

You are the friend who listens without judging.
The friend who always says yes.
The friend who offers advice, emotional support, connections, money, opportunities, or reassurance.
You are useful. You are available. You make their lives easier.
  • But what happens when you stop playing that role?
  • What happens when you become unavailable?
  • What happens when you start saying no?
  • What happens when you need the same patience, attention, and emotional support you have been giving them?

Suddenly, the relationship feels different.
They may call you selfish.
They may accuse you of changing.
They may become distant, irritated, or strangely uninterested.
And you begin wondering whether you have done something wrong.

But consider another possibility.
Perhaps you have not become a worse friend.
Perhaps you have simply stopped being as convenient.

There is a significant difference between being valued as a person and being valued for what you provide.

Psychologists studying interpersonal relationships distinguish between relationships characterized by mutual care and those driven primarily by personal benefits.

In a healthy relationship, people care about each other’s well-being, not merely what they can obtain.
This does not mean every friendship must be perfectly selfless. All relationships involve some form of exchange.

But when affection disappears the moment your usefulness disappears, you have learned something important.
Some people miss what you did for them more than they miss you.

That realization can be painful.
It can also be liberating.
Because once you understand the difference, you become much more careful about where you invest your time, energy, and emotional availability.


6. Losing Friends Can Reveal How Much of Your Identity Was Built Around Being Accepted
There is another reason losing friends can feel disproportionately painful.
Sometimes, we are not only losing a relationship.
We are losing a version of ourselves.

Think about how much of your identity may have been connected to a particular social circle.
You were the funny one.
The reliable one.
The person everyone called when they needed advice.
The friend who organized gatherings and remembered everyone’s important dates.

You knew where you belonged.
Then the friendship changes.
Suddenly, you no longer know what your role is.
You may even begin questioning your personality.
  • Am I difficult to love?
  • Am I boring?
  • Did I become less interesting?
  • Did I say something wrong?
This is where social psychology becomes particularly relevant.

Humans have a fundamental need to belong. Research by psychologists Roy Baumeister and Mark Leary, published in 1995, argued that the need to form and maintain meaningful interpersonal relationships is a fundamental human motivation.

Social rejection can therefore feel like more than disappointment. 
It can threaten our sense of belonging and emotional security.

But there is an important distinction between belonging and dependence.
Belonging allows you to be yourself while remaining connected to others.
Dependence makes you feel that you must become someone else to preserve the connection.
One creates security.
The other creates anxiety.

And perhaps the greatest lesson of losing a friendship is discovering how much of your behavior was designed to avoid rejection.
  1. You may have laughed at jokes you disliked.
  2. Agreed with opinions you did not share.
  3. Hidden your ambitions because someone might feel threatened.
  4. Avoided difficult conversations because you feared creating distance.
You thought you were maintaining harmony.
But perhaps you were gradually abandoning authenticity.

The right friendships do not require you to become a smaller version of yourself.
Sometimes losing people is the beginning of recovering the parts of yourself you sacrificed to keep them.


7. The Most Dangerous Mistake Is Repeating the Same Friendship With Different People
Here is where the story becomes even more interesting.

You lose one friend.
You promise yourself that you will never tolerate the same behavior again.
You become more cautious.
You pay closer attention to people’s actions.
You tell yourself that you have learned your lesson.

Then, months or years later, something familiar happens.
A new person enters your life.
They seem different. They have a different personality, background, and way of communicating.
But gradually, the same emotional pattern appears.

You become the listener.
They become the person who needs constant understanding.
You initiate contact.
They respond when convenient.
You make compromises.
They establish expectations.

Eventually, you find yourself asking the same questions you asked in the previous friendship.

Why am I always the one trying?
Why do I feel guilty for having boundaries?
Why does this relationship make me feel so unimportant?

This is not necessarily a coincidence.
It may reflect a recurring interpersonal pattern.

Psychologists have studied how early attachment experiences, expectations, and learned relationship behaviors can influence the relationships people form later in life.
We sometimes gravitate toward familiar emotional dynamics, even when those dynamics are unhealthy.

Familiarity can feel like compatibility.
Intensity can feel like intimacy.
Being needed can feel like being loved.

And the danger is that you may mistake a familiar emotional experience for a healthy connection.

Jung’s work on unconscious patterns offers a useful philosophical warning here: what remains unexamined can continue influencing our lives without our awareness.

The names change.
The faces change.
The circumstances change.
But the underlying pattern remains.

If you want different friendships, you may need to change more than the people you choose.
You may need to change what you are willing to accept.

Ask yourself:
  1. Do I feel comfortable expressing disagreement with this person?
  2. Can I say no without fearing punishment or withdrawal?
  3. Does this person show interest in my life when they need nothing from me?
  4. Can I be vulnerable without feeling that my honesty will eventually be used against me?
  5. Do I feel more like myself after spending time with them, or less?

These questions may reveal more about a friendship than years of casual conversations.
And they may save you from repeating a painful chapter with a different cast of characters.



8. The Moment You Stop Chasing Is the Moment You Discover Who Actually Cares
There is a particular kind of exhaustion that comes from constantly trying to maintain a connection.

You send the message.
You suggest the meeting.
You remember the important dates.
You ask how they are doing.
You apologize first, even when you are not entirely sure what you did wrong.

You become the person responsible for keeping the friendship alive.
Eventually, you become tired.
Not necessarily angry.
Just tired.

And one day, you decide to stop initiating.
You stop sending the first message.
You stop creating opportunities to meet.
You stop filling every silence.

At first, the silence feels unbearable.
You check your phone.
You wonder whether they noticed.
You consider sending another message.
You tell yourself that perhaps you are being immature.

But something interesting happens when you allow relationships to exist without constantly managing them.
You begin to see patterns more clearly.
Some people reach out.
Some make an effort.
Some notice your absence.
Others disappear completely.

However, there is an important caution: do not turn silence into a secret loyalty test. People have demanding lives, different communication habits, and periods of genuine difficulty.
One unanswered message does not prove that someone never cared.
  1. Look at the pattern, not a single moment.
  2. Look at whether care is mutual over time.
  3. Look at whether the person makes an effort when the relationship requires something from them.
You do not need to manipulate people into proving their affection.
You simply need to stop doing all the work for two people.
A healthy friendship should not require one person to continuously convince the other person that the relationship matters.
Sometimes, stepping back is not a strategy to make someone miss you.
It is a way to discover whether the relationship can stand without your constant effort.
And that is a very different kind of freedom.


9. You Do Not Have to Hate Someone to Outgrow Them
Perhaps the most mature response to a broken friendship is not anger.
It is acceptance.
  • You do not have to expose someone.
  • You do not have to write a long message explaining every disappointment.
  • You do not have to make them regret losing you.
  • You do not even have to decide that they were a terrible person.
Some friendships end because people change.
Some end because values become incompatible.
Some end because one person repeatedly violates the other’s boundaries.
Others simply belong to a particular chapter of life.

The fact that a relationship has ended does not mean every moment within it was meaningless.
  • You can appreciate what someone once meant to you without giving them permanent access to your life.
  • You can forgive someone without trusting them again.
  • You can wish someone well without inviting them back.
  • You can remember the good times without pretending the painful ones never happened.
This is an important distinction between forgiveness and reconciliation.
Forgiveness is a personal process. 
Reconciliation requires participation, accountability, and a willingness to rebuild trust from both sides.

You are not obligated to restore a relationship simply because you have released your anger.
Nor do you need to carry resentment to justify walking away.

Sometimes, the healthiest ending is a quiet one.
No dramatic announcement.
No revenge.
No final performance.

Just a decision to stop investing in a relationship that no longer reflects the life you want to build.
That is not bitterness.
That is emotional maturity.



10. The People Who Stay Will Teach You a Different Definition of Friendship
After losing a few friendships, you may become suspicious of everyone.

You may hesitate before trusting someone.
You may interpret delayed messages as rejection.
You may wonder whether every act of kindness comes with an invisible price.

This is understandable.
But do not allow disappointing relationships to turn you into someone who cannot recognize genuine affection.

The answer to being hurt is not to become emotionally unavailable.
It is to become more discerning.

Real friendship is not necessarily loud, constant, or dramatic.
Sometimes, it looks surprisingly ordinary.
  1. It is the person who remembers something you told them weeks ago.
  2. The person who can disagree with you without humiliating you.
  3. The person who celebrates your success without making it about themselves.
  4. The person who does not disappear when your life becomes inconvenient.
  5. The person who allows you to be imperfect without making you feel unworthy of connection.
  6. And perhaps most importantly, it is the person with whom you do not have to perform.
You do not have to be successful, entertaining, useful, agreeable, or endlessly available.
You can have a difficult day.
You can say no.
You can change your mind.
You can grow in a direction they do not fully understand.

And the relationship does not immediately become a negotiation.
That is what emotional safety looks like.
Not perfection.
Not constant agreement.
But mutual respect, consistency, and the freedom to be yourself.



The Final Truth: 
Sometimes Losing People Is How You Find Yourself
One day, you may look back at a friendship you once desperately tried to save.
You may remember the messages you sent, the compromises you made, the nights you spent wondering what went wrong.
And perhaps you will finally understand something you could not understand at the time.

You were not asking for too much.
You were asking the wrong relationship to provide something it could not consistently give.
  1. You wanted loyalty from someone who offered convenience.
  2. You wanted emotional intimacy from someone who preferred superficial connection.
  3. You wanted mutual effort from someone who was comfortable letting you do all the work.
And you kept waiting because accepting the truth felt more painful than maintaining the illusion.
But eventually, the illusion became more exhausting than the truth.
That is when something changes.

You stop chasing explanations.
You stop trying to convince people to understand your value.
You stop confusing history with loyalty.
You stop believing that because someone has known you for ten years, they automatically deserve another ten.
And you begin to understand that the length of a friendship does not determine its depth.

Carl Jung’s work invites us to look beyond appearances and examine the unconscious expectations shaping our relationships.
Perhaps one of the most valuable lessons we can take from that work is this:
  • You cannot build an authentic life while remaining loyal to an illusion.
  • Not every person who leaves was pretending.
  • Not every friendship that ends was meaningless.
  • And not everyone who disappoints you is a villain.
But you must learn to recognize the difference between a relationship that is imperfect and one that repeatedly requires you to abandon yourself.
Because your life is too short to spend it auditioning for a place in someone else’s.

One day, you will meet people who do not make you question whether you matter.
Until then, learn to be comfortable walking away from relationships that require you to forget that you do.

And remember:

You haven’t necessarily lost everyone who walked away. Sometimes, you’ve simply stopped losing yourself trying to make them stay.




A Question Worth Sitting With
Think about the friendships that have ended in your life.

Were you grieving the person, the memories, the future you imagined together, or the version of yourself who believed that friendship would last forever?

And perhaps the more difficult question:

Are you holding on to someone today because you genuinely value the relationship—or because you are afraid to accept what it has become?

Your answer may tell you more than you expect.




in, The Psychology Reset




sábado, 14 de novembro de 2026

Keeping Quiet


Reza Estakhrian






Now we will count to twelve
and we will all keep still
for once on the face of the earth,
let’s not speak in any language;
let’s stop for a second,
and not move our arms so much.

It would be an exotic moment
without rush, without engines;
we would all be together
in a sudden strangeness.

Fishermen in the cold sea
would not harm whales
and the man gathering salt
would not look at his hurt hands.

Those who prepare green wars,
wars with gas, wars with fire,
victories with no survivors,
would put on clean clothes
and walk about with their brothers
in the shade, doing nothing.

What I want should not be confused
with total inactivity.

Life is what it is about…

If we were not so single-minded
about keeping our lives moving,
and for once could do nothing,
perhaps a huge silence
might interrupt this sadness
of never understanding ourselves
and of threatening ourselves with
death.

Now I’ll count up to twelve
and you keep quiet and I will go.


Pablo Neruda


 

The Fish in the Dry Rut


Tifenn Degornet
 





On the great help 
we promise for later, 
and the small help 
that is needed today





Zhuangzi was poor for most of his life. One day, when there was no grain left at home, he went to ask a local lord for a loan.

The lord greeted him warmly. 
“Of course,” he said. “My taxes will come in soon. When they do, I will lend you three hundred pieces of gold. Will that do?”
Zhuangzi’s face went red. Instead of answering, he told the lord a story.
“On my way here yesterday,” he said, “I heard a voice calling me. I looked down and saw a carp lying in the rut of a cart track, in the last bit of water left there. It asked me for a bucket of water to keep it alive.

“I told it: of course. I am travelling south soon to visit two kings. I will ask them to send the whole West River up here to meet you. Will that do?

“The carp went red with anger. It said: I am out of water and I have nowhere to go. One bucket would save me. If that is your answer, you will find me later at the dried fish shop.”



Why the promise of a river hurts
The story is funny, and it is meant to be. But the anger in it is real.

The lord does not refuse to help. 
He offers far more than he was asked for: 
gold instead of grain, a river instead of a bucket. 
The problem is that his help will arrive too late to be of any use.

That is what makes the carp so angry. It does not need a river. It needs a little water, now, before the rut dries out.

I think this is why the story has lasted for more than two thousand years. 
Most of us have been the carp at some point in our lives. 
And most of us have also been the lord.


The rivers we promise ourselves
We often play both roles at once, inside our own lives.

Many of us are waiting for a river of our own. 
The long holiday that will finally let us recover. The move, the new job, the year when things calm down. We put all our hope in one big change, and in the meantime we give ourselves nothing.

But the river is always still on its way. It depends on taxes that have not come in yet, on a journey that keeps being postponed. 
And while we wait, the water in the rut keeps drying up.

What we need in the meantime is usually very small. 
A quiet hour on a Sunday. A walk at lunchtime. An early night without feeling guilty. These seem almost silly next to the river we have been promising ourselves, and that is exactly why we keep putting them off.

In The Wisdom of the Right Timing, I talked about waiting with trust instead of anxiety. 
The lord in this story shows a different kind of waiting. 
It has nothing to do with trust. It is a polite way of putting off what could be done today.


The rivers we promise others
The story is first of all about two people, and this is where it touches us most.

A friend is going through a hard time, and we say: we must have a proper dinner soon. What they needed was a short phone call tonight. An ageing parent is lonely, and we plan the long talk we will have with them one day. A short visit this week would have meant more.

The big gesture feels more worthy of the person we love. That is its trap. Because it needs time or money or a free weekend, it keeps slipping away, and the small gesture never feels big enough to bother with.

The carp does not want to be honoured. It wants to be kept alive. Most people who are struggling are the same. They are not waiting for our grand plans. They would be grateful for a bucket.



What a bucket of water looks like
If you would like to take one thing from this story, I would suggest asking yourself a question this week, twice.

First about yourself: 
What small thing do I keep refusing myself while I wait for a big change? 
Usually, it is something that could be done before Sunday.

Then about someone else: 
Who around me is in a dry rut right now, and what is the smallest real help I could give before the week is over?

A message, a meal dropped off, half an hour of listening. It will feel like too little. For the person in the rut, it may be what matters most.

Great plans are still allowed. The story does not forbid them. It only asks that they stop being a reason to give nothing today.





in, Words of Taoism