What is coercive control,
how does it work, and
why is it so difficult to see
while you are living inside it?
I have had relationships where the emotional and mental burden of the situation became so great that I began to believe that I no longer had full ownership over my own life. Constantly having to second-guess how your message will be received and read by the other person makes even the simplest communication a long and drawn-out process. Sometimes you just want to know when they will be home. You might want to make plans for the weekend. You may want to talk to them about something that happened the previous night. But instead of just going ahead and doing that, you need to find a way to figure out if that’s something they will be receptive to.
Communication becomes a calculation.
You remove the sentence that sounds too direct. But you realize that your softer version is probably going to be interpreted as passive aggressive. You end up adding an extra-long sentence to provide justification and then realize you’re justifying yourself too much and end up deleting the extra-long sentence. Now you just sit and stare at your screen. Eventually you take the plunge and send the message. It is probably quite different from what you actually wanted to say.
Maybe there’s no message at all. You hear the front door open, and you subconsciously judge how it closes. You can read body language to determine how best to proceed. You can listen to footsteps and get a sense of their mood. Sometimes you decide against saying something you were going to say. You know you are putting something off, but may have no explanation for why.
You may not think of this as fear, especially at first.
People often expect fear to have an obvious threat attached to it.
Losing a sense of control can instead leave you mentally exhausted from making calculations all the time. As decisions become more difficult, you may start to doubt your ability to make them without second-guessing yourself.
Much of this calculation happens without conscious thought. With control, however, calculating your options can become difficult and time-consuming.
This is one reason coercive control can be difficult to recognize for a long time.
When control develops gradually, the smaller changes may not seem particularly significant. Your life may still look much the way it always did, and nobody has literally prevented you from leaving. Smaller changes are also easier to rationalize, particularly when they happen over a prolonged period of time.
You get used to having another person in the background of your day.
Understanding coercive control
Not all conflict is an indication of control. One person can become defensive and say things they later regret, and the two people involved can remain separate individuals. One person can’t dictate how the other person interprets what was said, felt, or remembered.
One person can gradually gain influence over another person’s decisions without ever openly claiming or asserting control over them.
People can argue over things, and one person can ultimately give in. That person is still free to make the same choice again, but may become less and less likely to do so in order to avoid the outcome they already know may follow.
A major reason I don’t like it when people refer to situations like this as “toxic” is because the term is used so broadly that it can become almost meaningless.
Coercive control describes something more specific.A person’s choices become increasingly restricted by another person until they have much less control over how they live their own life. This does not always require someone to explicitly tell the other person what they can or cannot do. A person may gradually begin changing their own choices because they already know what is likely to happen afterward.
Relationships don’t start with control.
It is something that happens gradually over time.
Generally, it happens over the course of a series of minor events.
- You might start to realize you will disagree about the same things and end up arguing about it repeatedly.
- You also start to learn things that will upset the other person and end up having to defend yourself for bringing it up.
Often, the situations happen enough times that you learn to manage which things you say to the other person and learn to control things to an even greater degree.
Eventually, people learn to preemptively identify the issues that are better left unaddressed.
At that point, the person is no longer simply participating in a relationship.They are managing a system.
The difference is easy to miss because management can look remarkably similar to compromise when you are living it.
The distinction becomes clear when you ask what would happen if you stopped managing it.
Over time, you learn which things will start an argument.
You know when something will upset them, and sometimes it seems easier to change what you were going to do. It may not feel like anyone is making the decision for you.
That is part of what makes coercive control difficult to recognize. You can still have choices and find yourself making fewer of them.
The methods of control
Someone who has known you for a long time will naturally know things about you that other people do not.
Surveillance and implicit rules
Surveillance can be as overt as tracking someone’s location or as covert as noticing minor changes and altering one’s behavior in response. They may begin to take note of the minor details in the manner you communicate. Surveillance may also take the form of how long you take before responding to their questions or statements. You may also notice your partner taking interest in minor details that you consider unimportant such as your choice of attire, the food you eat, and the way you interact with your coworkers or family members.
In a coercive relationship, minor details about a person are retained for use at a later date.
Returning home later than normal may result in you having to answer questions you do not want to answer. You may have to explain why you need privacy. People can read your emotions and come up with their own conclusions as to what you may be feeling. They assume you’re angry. You may try to explain something to them, but they tend to focus on your facial expressions instead of listening to what you have to say. You get used to feeling powerless and accepting things as they assume them to be.
I think unwritten rules are more dangerous than explicit rules. Written rules can be contested. One can identify their unreasonableness and possibly come to an understanding as to why they should not follow the rule. With an implicit rule, you only realize you broke it once you are punished for it.
Worse, getting it right does not guarantee much. What prevented an argument last month may provoke one today. The problem is that the rules can change depending on what the other person wants that day. Just when you think you have figured them out, something that was fine before is suddenly wrong.
Reality editing
You remember one thing, but they insist something else happened.
Gaslighting has been used so often it has lost some of its impact. Usually, people only claim to have been gaslighted when an issue is too complicated for them to effectively rebut. Just because someone provides a contrary account to your recollection of an event, that does not mean they are gaslighting you. It is entirely possible for two people to disagree on the particulars of a recollection of a conversation or event.
I still remember presenting a case involving coercive control during my psychiatry residency in Boston and using the word gaslighting. One of our older psychologists, who was there as a mentor, stopped me and asked what it meant. I was genuinely surprised. I assumed that a term taken from a famous 1944 movie had somehow entered everyone’s vocabulary decades before I arrived in the United States. Apparently, it had not.
The term “gaslighting” originates from the film Gaslight, directed by George Cukor. In the film, Greg intentionally manipulates Paula and repeatedly denies things she has actually experienced. The dimming gaslights are one example. Greg insists that what Paula sees is not happening and gradually causes her to doubt her own sanity. This is considerably more deceptive than the lying and ordinary disagreement that we now sometimes describe as gaslighting.
Paula’s situation is extreme, but I have witnessed less dramatic versions of something similar. Something hurtful happens and then the conversation changes. Instead of talking about what happened, the discussion becomes about whether the other person understood it correctly. When this happens repeatedly, some people begin keeping records of conversations. They may save a message or write something down shortly afterward because they want a record of what happened before their memory of it is questioned.
I think such impulse is interesting from a psychological standpoint. Generally, we do not keep mementos for our conversations with friends and family. We can usually accept that our memory of a contentious discussion is incomplete and perhaps different from another person’s memory of the same discussion. Many people feel the need to create a record of something if they think there is a risk that their memory of the event will not sufficiently protect them. For example, people often save texts or emails if they think someone may subsequently lie or distort the truth about something.
The problem with having proof is that it does not always solve the problem. Eventually you find the message and then the debate is about context. You remember the words and the debate is about the interpretation. Eventually you amass a lot of evidence and very little closure because closure may have never been the reason the debate was started.
Isolation and dependency
Nobody has to tell you that you cannot see your friends. You go out one evening, have a perfectly good time, and then come home to a problem. Maybe there is an argument. Maybe the rest of the night feels tense. Somehow this friend is always a problem, or your mother becomes one whenever you have been talking to her more often. You get to a point where you start turning down invitations because you already know what the evening afterward is likely to be like. Nobody actually told you to stay home. You started doing that yourself.
It isn’t necessarily the case that you start to have fewer friends. You can have twenty people in your phone and still become increasingly alone if you don’t have anybody you can honestly talk to about your relationship.
Of course, being isolated from the rest of the world has consequences beyond loneliness. There are times when you need other people to reflect things to you that have lost their meaning through constant repetition. There are things that you can take years to tell yourself, explain only once to another person, and have that person say or think things that help you understand and reconcile with the past. For example, you can spend years describing to yourself how another person hurt you. When you finally explain it to your friend, they can end up asking, “He did what?” That friend might help us edit our reality to include a new perspective from a third party who has not been involved. This can help reframe and define a confusing and often irreconcilable piece of your reality.
Psychoanalysts have long been interested in how external forces of control and dominance can become internalized within the mind. Freud wrote about how the superego serves as an internal moral authority. Later analysts describe ways in which relationship with powerful and frightening people can become a part of the self.
After enough time, the controlling person does not have to be present for control to continue.
You already know what they would say. You also know which idea would start an argument, what they would question, or what you would probably have to explain afterward. So sometimes you decide against something before mentioning it at all. It may take a while before you notice what has happened. Nobody objected this time, nobody had to. You had already done it for them.
Punishment followed by relief
It would be easier to recognize control if the other person were horrible all the time. Control isn’t that clear cut, however. You can have a really bad fight, then the next day get an apology that sounds like it is really from the heart. A few hours later you may be having a dinner together and laughing again. Reconciliation can bring temporary relief. After several days of tension, it can feel especially good when things finally seem normal again. Relief can become part of what keeps people coming back. Behavior that is reinforced unpredictably can become remarkably persistent.
Not everything in relationships can be studied the way behavior in the laboratory can. I don’t mean to suggest that the explanation for love is conditioning. But the idea of unpredictable relief can help explain something people sometimes feel embarrassed about afterward. When you never know when things will be good again, the good periods can become unusually important.
Relief feels different when you have spent days waiting for it.
Things feel normal again, and there is no particular reason in that moment to assume they will go wrong again. The apology may also be completely sincere.
And sometimes they mean it. A few days later, though, you may find yourself having almost the same argument again.
Not all apologies or shows of affection are manipulative. Sometimes a person really is sorry after a fight. People don’t always lie, sometimes they truly believe what they are telling you. They may be sorry and mean well, and then have another fight that brings things back to where they once were. Often, it’s things like jealousy, anger, or fear that bring about the repeated negative behaviors of a person. That being said, just because a person slips up and acts negatively towards you repeatedly doesn’t mean that everything else they say or feel is insincere.
Certain situations in your life often become easy to predict. That knowledge can lead you to avoid decisions that you already know may have negative outcomes. Eventually, you know what to expect and how to act based on your previous experiences. Sometimes this happens so many times that you nearly lose the ability to make the choice. But sometimes, the other person never actually has to make the choice for you in the first place. You already know what their response is likely to be, and you make the choice before they have a chance to.
What it feels like to live inside it.
You keep many parts of your normal life while living this way. This is sometimes hard to grasp for people around you. Sometimes when you meet someone new, they won’t understand how you can go to work and seem to function normally. But most people only see the parts of your life that you show them. You manage your life in a way that keeps everything looking okay to the outside world, sometimes at great personal cost.
I have met patients who appeared to be thriving in other areas of their life despite not feeling like themselves.
I believe this is one reason spotting coercive control in others can be challenging. Most of us expect a person who is losing themselves to show some obvious sign of it. However, this isn’t always the case.
You may not notice these changes in someone at all.
For example, a person may gradually stop speaking their mind and start censoring themselves without really noticing when it began.
Some things can happen so often over the years that you become highly adept at managing them without thinking. One such example is managing expectations. A large part of managing expectations can involve dealing with potentially contentious or emotionally draining situations. This can eat up a lot of your time and mental bandwidth.
There are other things, such as feeling guilty for wanting to do something as simple as spending an evening by yourself. In fact, you may feel guilty about wanting this before you have even said anything. Because of this, you may already be thinking about how you are going to explain wanting the evening to yourself.
There are other forms of guilt as well. Normally, guilt follows something we believe we have done wrong. With someone who is controlling, it can begin to show up simply because something you decided to do made the other person unhappy. Eventually these feelings can start to feel the same, even though you are fully aware that you have not necessarily done anything wrong.
This has occurred to people I consider to be highly capable. There is a tendency to believe people who have experienced coercive control were passive or dependent to begin with. Having the ability to operate and function in the world is not an impediment to adapting to a controlling relationship. Some people are quick to pick up the behaviors of others and are able to identify the reasons for those behaviors.
Sometimes people understand another person so well that they begin to explain away behavior that is controlling or abusive.
Frequently, people are able to adapt and function in the situations they previously would have been unable to tolerate. People may become so accustomed to functioning under a high level of stress that they are able to tolerate circumstances they could not have handled before.
They may even be proud of how much they have learned to handle, and there may be good reason for that. Being able to function in high-stress situations, however, doesn’t necessarily mean that a person is freer.
I have known people who only realized near the end of a relationship or afterward how much they had learned to put up with and manage during it. Some had become adept at functioning while managing an enormous amount.
Sometimes people are surprised to discover how quiet their lives have become. There are no immediate crises that require management, and nobody needs an explanation. Sometimes people are not quite sure what to do with the freedom they now have.
These changes occur gradually. There is usually a reason for making a particular change when it happens. Over a period of time, a series of minor changes may become so great that a person looks back and realizes they have not felt quite like themselves for a long time.
Sometimes people become so used to changing and adapting to other people that they lose sight of the cost of adapting. A person may become so skilled at it that they are able to manage their daily life without feeling really present in it.
The moment you begin to see it
I don’t believe something particularly dramatic has to happen for coercive control to become apparent. Constantly analyzing your own thoughts can get tiring.
You find yourself analyzing the other person’s feelings and behavior.
- What led them to act that way?
- Are they feeling jealous? Frightened? Under too much pressure?
- Is there something unresolved from the past that is causing them to act this way?
- Did I say something that offended them?
- What if I had stayed quiet?
- Should I have waited to speak to them on another occasion? Would it have made a difference? Would they have opened up to me then?
These questions can take up a great deal of your time. Some of the explanations you come up with may even be correct. But understanding why something is happening does not necessarily help with the fear and suffering of repeatedly experiencing it.
I found this concept important in my practice when thinking about intent.
The main problem with intent is that a person can never be completely sure about another person’s internal motivations. Sometimes, you can spend a lot of time evaluating whether someone has acted with the intent to control you, and you may never come to a satisfactory conclusion.
Looking at an individual’s behavior gives you something else to consider.
You may begin noticing how the person acts when you do not agree with them, especially when you do not try to explain yourself.
What happens when you make a decision they would not have made?
You may also begin noticing how differently you act when they are around.
The person may continue to say the same things, and perhaps believe them. However, you may no longer accept what they say as the truth.
Just because you understand what is going on, does not mean it gets any easier. I have seen people recognize the problems in their relationships and still want to stay with that person and love them. There are a million reasons that might make someone want to leave, but sometimes knowing what you want to do and what you should do are completely different things.
Understanding and leaving are two different things.
Something will eventually change if you stop fighting what you know to be true.
Something happens, and instead of immediately asking whether you misunderstood it, overreacted, remembered it incorrectly, or had any right to be upset, you allow yourself to remember what happened the way you remember it.
The other person may disagree. Your memory does not have to disappear because of that.
At first, this will probably feel strange. You’ve spent so much time questioning yourself instead.
I think you start to make your own small choices here.
People usually think about the large, significant choices when leaving.
But leaving might start with smaller choices.
- You start to notice little things that you never would’ve seen as choices.
- You realize you’re allowed to have your own thoughts, and you don’t have to ask anyone else if those thoughts are okay.
Just knowing all of this doesn’t mean your old responses disappear.
You may still react the way you always have.
VERA HART

Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário